Types of Argument

?
  • Created by: rhyswinz
  • Created on: 17-04-17 17:31

Deductive arguments

  • Deduction is taking a set of statements (premises), and drawing an inescapable conclusion from them.
  • If the premises are true then the conclusion must be true.
  • Deductive arguments are usually used for logical/mathematical reasoning.

E.g:
Premise: Birmingham is a city in the West Midlands. The West Midlands is a region in England.
Conclusion: Therefore, Birmingham is a city in England. (true)

E.g:
Premise: Butterflies have wings. Birds have wings.
Conclusion: Butterflies are birds. (not true)

1 of 5

Inductive arguments

  • It develops conclusions from particular observations.
  • The premises are seemed to provide reasons for supporting the probable truth of a conclusion.
  • It is seen as the cornerstone of the scientific world.

E.g: 
Argument: For the past 50 years is hase rained on April 1st in the Lake District. Therefore it will rain in the Lake District on April 1st next year.
Evaluation: The conclusion cannot be certain, but it may be very likely.

2 of 5

Arguments from authority

  • These are seen as arguments from an 'expert' in a subject.
  • Regarded as a weak form of argument as any two experts may disagree.
  • An 'authority' may be biased or not representative of most experts in the field.
  • Arguments can be described as a fallacy (an error in reasoning, i.e. it cannot be supported)
  • It is NOT a factual error.
3 of 5

Arguments from analogy

  • The most deceptive kind of argument.
  • They depend on situations appearing to be the same.
  • You then conclude that the causes of those situations are the same.
  • These arguments are popular in everyday life.
  • The conclusion from these arguments can only ever be 'possibly true'.

E.g: 

  • Political arguments
  • Religious arguments
  • Cultural arguments
4 of 5

Causal arguments

  • This is a weak form of argument.
  • It claims that one thing happens as a direct cause of something which occured previously.
  • Often it is only a correlation between the two events and they can have two very different causes.

E.g: 

  • Smoking causes cancer.
5 of 5

Comments

No comments have yet been made

Similar General Studies resources:

See all General Studies resources »See all Challenges for Society resources »