Miracles Revision Notes

HideShow resource information
  • Created by: DAFE16
  • Created on: 27-02-17 19:39

Miracles Revision Notes

Miracles Definition

  • The General definition of a miracles is an event which cannot be accounted for or established by the laws of nature, which it appears to break, and is then attributed to God/supernatural causes.
  • There are various definitions of miracles, associated to various scholars
  • Augustine's definition: "whatever is hard or appears unusual beyond the expectation or comprehension of the observer"
  • Aquinas' definition: "Those things must properly be called miraculous which are done by divine power apart from the order generally followed in things."
  • Hume's definition: "transgession of a law of nature by a particular volition of the Deity or by the interposition of some invisible agent."
  • Holland's definition: "A coincidence can be taken religiously as a sign and called a miracle."
  • Hume's definition implies that miracles are violations of the laws of nature, which coincides with the word miracles from Latin, as sth. amazing or unexpected (e.g. Burning Bush)
  • Holland's definition implies sth. more ordinary, but with a religious significance - nevertheless, loses this awe-inspiring thought of a miracle (e.g. West Baptist Church)

Biblical Miracles

  • The  are several miracles in the Bible, such as: Water into wine (John 2), Feeds the 5,000 (Matt 14), Raises Lazarus from the dead (John 11), crossing the Red Sea (Ex 14) and Sun stands still (Jos 10)
  • The are various purposes of miracles in the Bible: Love and compassion of God, God's power, shows an immanent God and shows that Jesus is God
  • There are different ways to understanding miracles in the Bible (=different ways to interpret the Bible): Literal, symbolic and liberal
  • Criticisms to the idea of miracles in the Bible, as shown above:
  • Form Criticism - what was the form in which the story was told? (Hermann Gauckel)
  • Rudolf Bultmann - demythologising the Bible: removing the true message from supernatural elements to it
  • Conservatives belief that miracles weren't additions to the orginial account, but integrations: if Christ did not resurrect - no Christianity

Hume on Miracles

  • David Hume puts forward to different types of argument against the idea of miracles: the theoretical and the practical arguments
  • In the theoretical argument, Hume argues against the very definition of miracles (the one he formualted), the argument goes like this:
  • The laws of nature are uniform, e.g. the sun rises every day
  • Induction is based on cause and effect - this means that the events observed suggests that the opposite will not happen, e.g. the sun always rises, therefore it will…


No comments have yet been made

Similar Religious Studies resources:

See all Religious Studies resources »See all Philosophy resources »