Strengths and Weaknesses of Situation Ethics


Strengths and Weaknesses of Situation Ethics


  • Easy to understand - can be constantly updated for new problems/issues, e.g genetic engineering
  • Flexible - takes different situations into account, but based on Christian concept of agape love.
  • Focuses on human concern for others
  • Allows people to take responsibility for own actions, make up own minds about what's right/wrong


  • Condemned by Pope Pius XII- wrong to make decisions based on individual circumstances if they went against Church teaching
  • Impossible to determine consequences of actions - most loving result = unknown


Situation ethics is seen as a kinder and more flexible theory than its more absolute counterparts - however, it has received criticism from religious leaders for its disregard of traditional Christian faith


No comments have yet been made