Psychology Case Studies Piliavin

  • Created by: Melissa
  • Created on: 30-10-13 14:05
Piliavin's research method
Field experiment (Had IV's and DV's but experiment took place in natural location (NY Subway)).
1 of 20
Piliavin's independent variables were...
Type of victim (ill or drunk); Race of victim (black or white); Presence of helping models; Size of witnessing group.
2 of 20
Piliavin's dependent variables were...
Number and speed of helpers; Race and gender of helpers; Movement out of critical area; Verbal comments.
3 of 20
Piliavin's controls
Same train route; Roles within teams; Collapse time (70 seconds in to journey); Appearance of victim; Help times from model; Time of day (11am - 3pm); Position of team members in carriage
4 of 20
Piliavin's sample
Approx. 4450 unsolicited subjects; 55% white and 45% black; Mean number of people in carriage over all trials 45; Mean number of people in critical area 8.5).
5 of 20
Piliavin's sampling method
Opportunity sample (whoever was on the train at the time of the trials).
6 of 20
Strengths of Piliavin's sample
Large sample size and good variation of types of people
7 of 20
Weaknesses of Piliavin's sample
All got something in common - large part of the population wouldn't be on the train at that time so not representative; Some participants may have seen the experiment more than once
8 of 20
Strengths of Piliavin's sampling method
Quick; Convenient, Cheap; No demand characteristics (natural behaviour since they don't know they're being observed).
9 of 20
Weaknesses of Piliavin's sampling method
Participants hadn't given consent or were debriefed afterwards making it unethical.
10 of 20
Quantitative results from Piliavin's study
62/65 helped on cane trials with avg help time of 5 seconds compared to 19/38 people helping on drunk trials with avg time of 109 seconds; 90% of the helpers were male; 34 people left the critical area over all the trials.
11 of 20
Qualitative results from Piliavin's study
From women about why they weren't helping - "It's for men to help" and "You feel so bad you don't know what to do.
12 of 20
Explanation of Piliavin's study
Diffusion of responsibility wasn't apparent as help was given quickly. Instead, witnessing the fall caused arousal in the passengers. The costs/rewards influenced the decision to help. Less costs and more rewards for helping ill person.
13 of 20
Ethical guidelines for Piliavin's study
UPHELD: Confidentiality; BROKEN: Deception, Consent, Debrief, Harm, Withdrawal
14 of 20
Piliavin's study has HEV because...
It was conducted on the NY Subway and the passengers didn't know they were being observed so they didn't show demand characteristics; Often see people fall.
15 of 20
Piliavin's study has LEV because...
Not usually in a confined space when people fall.
16 of 20
Was Piliavin's study reliable?
Yes because it was standardised so the procedure could be replicated and there were a lot of controls used. The results were consistent too.
17 of 20
Was Piliavin's study accurate?
No because it doesn't take into consideration people's circumstances (injured, pregnant etc) and it ignores the historical context and racist views.
18 of 20
Change Piliavin's location
Subway to Street as confined train may have meant different levels of help - More ethical (able to withdraw); Harder to observe and quantify people - Less help (able to continue walking).
19 of 20
Change the gender of the victim in Piliavin's study
Male and female - More generalisable and useful - More help in general because women help women; Costs associated with helping women are less.
20 of 20

Other cards in this set

Card 2


Piliavin's independent variables were...


Type of victim (ill or drunk); Race of victim (black or white); Presence of helping models; Size of witnessing group.

Card 3


Piliavin's dependent variables were...


Preview of the front of card 3

Card 4


Piliavin's controls


Preview of the front of card 4

Card 5


Piliavin's sample


Preview of the front of card 5
View more cards


No comments have yet been made

Similar Psychology resources:

See all Psychology resources »See all Core studies resources »