The nature of Sources - Archeological evidence

HideShow resource information
  • Created by: Alice
  • Created on: 07-04-13 10:05

Archeological evidence

Sources aren't evidence - they don't prove anything

  • the historian must prove it to lead to a certain conclusion
  • objects don't speak for themselves
1 of 11

Archeological sources

Make you feel 'in touch' with Pompeii

Types of sources include:

  • Inscriptions
  • remains of houses and building structures
  • plant remains
  • wall writings
  • furniture remains
  • painting
  • mosaics
  • wax tablets
  • objects of everyday life

Wallace - Hadrill says that much evidence doesn't correlate to what they believe to be a typical roman house

Mauri suggest mix of residential and commercial units evidents that pompeii was in decline

  • Hadrill disagrees
2 of 11

Inscriptions

Formal Inscriptions: civic charters and regubtious, dedications by wealthy citizens - e.g. funery inscriptions

Formal inscriptions provide evidence for

  • gates of construction
  • prominant families
  • structure of government + political players
3 of 11

Wall Writings

There were two types of wall writings: Graffeti and Public Notices

Public Notices

  • Professional - done by scriptors
  • white washed with lime then electoral notices written at night (clear streets)
  • PROGRAMMATA - electorial manifesto/slogans\
  • Edicata munerum - programs announcing shows
  • coming to ampitheatre

graffeti

  • lots of variety
  • shared thoughts (feelings, love, contempt, remembering dates, advertising services/fees, amateur poems, angry outbursts, ****
  • An individual source of information
  • Wallace Hadrill: Ancient graffiti can reveal vitality of everyday lives
  • gives an informal voice to people usually heard
4 of 11

Other Archeological information

Wax Tablets + Papyri: Information about business + legal documents

Decorative Arts: Frescoes, paintings, mosaics, sculptures, furnishings and patterned floors

Frescoes: provide information of greek infleunce and development of Romant art and changes in society

Decorative Gardens and household furnishings

5 of 11

Skeletons of Herculaneum

Preserved in good condition due to the thick layer of debris

Sarah Bisel- Biochemical analysis of bones + measurement

There are problems using Yoricle as evidence

  • Hard to dignose signs + symptoms
  • diseases not present on bones
6 of 11

Casts from Pompeii

Estelle Lazor: Studied skeletal remains of 300 individuals

Badly worn teeth: staple food info (pumice in bread ground teeth)

Studied found in pompeii was in good health and was very well nourished

7 of 11

Plant Remains

Welhelmina Jashemski: carried out studies into soil contours, root cavaties, carbonised plant remains and pollen

  • supplemented these with evidence from: Paintings
  • Archeologists gained a clearer picture of product + garden

Rekationship between town and countryside

  • discovery of vineyards and olive gardens
8 of 11

Literary Sources

Pliny the younger - letters to Tacitus (records what was believed at the time)

positive:

  • geographical clues used by volcanologists + first hand account of personal reactions

Negative

  • Tacitus requested response 25 years later, reliability?
  • purpose?
  • omissions?
  • Strabo
  • Vitruvious of architecture (appearances of houses and activities inside rooms)
  • Seneccaa
  • Pliny the Elder

*supplement these with graffeti and cicero and livy of the events of the eruption

9 of 11

Dating Objects

  • Stratigraphy
  • Stylistic Sequences
  • Using paintings (related to August Mav's Style)
  • Absolute and relative dating
10 of 11

Gaps in Evidence

  • Using hypothesis + testing
  • looking for evidence to support - however hard to do (due to insufficient evidence)
  • Incomplete excavations
11 of 11

Comments

No comments have yet been made

Similar History resources:

See all History resources »See all resources »