Language Change + Variation

Notes on researches including Social Class

HideShow resource information

Malcolm Petyt

Social Climbing in Bradford, W.Yorkshire - 1985

  • Petyt focused on the omission of the initial /h/ sound - H-dropping.
  • He measured the frequency of this across social classes.
  • His results followed the basic trend of greater regional accent use in working class, decreasing moving up the social class scale
    --> Lower working class speakers used it in almost all instances of /h/ initiated words 
    --> Upper-middle class speakers used it only app. 1 in 10 opportunities
  • Petyt then developed this; in instances of social mobility where an individual has moved up the socio-economic scale, they may modify their speech closer towards RP, making less use of H-dropping (etc)
  • From here he then found that speakers who have moved up try to implement this modification in their speech
    --> this resulted in hypercorrection and often resulting in incorrect vowel sounds 
1 of 11

Peter Trudgill

Vernacular in different registers, Norwich - 1974

  • Similar to Petyt, however looked at the distinction between males + females in each social class
  • He used four different contexts: reading a wordlist, reading a passage, formal conversation and casual conversation

  • Respondents treated the word list as a highly formalised activity hence they were highly conscious of pronunciation resulting in lower non-standard use.
  • Casual speech created most informal context, resulting in the possible observer's paradox. 

  • Trudgill's findings mirror Petyt's; upper classes used far less non-standard language than those of working classes
  • The use of gender allowed more results; women generally used non-standard  variants less frequently than men in all social classes
2 of 11

Jennifer Chesire

Peer groups, Reading - 1980s

  • Wider range of linguistic analysis than Petyt + Trudgill, focused on grammatical variants
  • Identified 11 non-standard features + measured frequency in speech of boys and girls in an adventure playground

  • Group A - middle-class, Group B - working-class 
  • Higher use of non-standard forms in Group B in 5 of 8 grammatical variants, roughly equal in 2 and lower use in 1
  • Possibly shows increased variability of younger language users
  • Chesire concluded that for all children, patterns of non-standard usage are an important part of identity for each group 
3 of 11

Howard Giles

Perception of 'trustworthiness' interpreted in different accent forms - 1970s

  • The same joke was told to people but in different accents
  • RP meant the mark of a person who was reliable, well-educated and confident
  • Regional varieties scored higher on friendliness, sincerity and were perceived to be more persuasive than RP
4 of 11

Social Variation Theory

Anti-Language - Michael Halliday

  • Explains forms of sociolect that arise to support subcultures seeking some sort of covert identity.
  • Often related to the idea of deviance - behaviour that is against normal practices of society + sometimes criminality

Michael Halliday identified nine common features

  • language of anti-society that exists within society as an alternative
  • word lists form main evidence of anti-languages
  • mostly formed by relexicalising existing vocabulary items
  • users communicate meanings that are inaccessible to non-users
  • subcultures w/ an anti-language view it as a fundamental part of their identity
  • conversation is main form of communication used to uphold the anti-lang
  • it is a vehicle of resocialisation
  • there is a continuity + exchange between language + anti-language
5 of 11

Koneisation

Koneisation

  • A new standard variety of language is formed by contact of two existing dialect forms of a language
  • The new koine form that emreges exists separately from source dialects + does not interfere with their use

Paul Kerswill - Milton Keynes - 1990s

  • Identified a regional koine in Milton Keynes as a result of speakers from the south relocating there in mid 20th-Century
    --> Milton Keynes saw large number of speakers come to it w/ existing regional dialect forms different from that spoken by natives
  • Kerswill identified that this emergence was a shared, standard form in the area representing the combination of native + incoming accent forms
    --> the distinct accent forms were retained by communities in their own language use
6 of 11

Dialect Levelling

Dialect Levelling

  • Strong relation to Estuary English
  • The gradual eradication of marked differences between local dialects or sociolect forms
  • Most commonly applied to changes in accent features of regional forms in recent decades

Kerswill - Milton Keynes + Reading - 1990s

  • Estuary English seen as a variety weilding strong influence over localised, regional dialects
  • Features found in Milton Keynes, i.e. fronting vowel sounds, were of a similar fashion to EE; similar patterns were found in Reading

- Jane Stuart-smith found that TH fronting and the glottal stop were emerging in Glaswegian accents, but not that EE was supplanting the dialect.

7 of 11

Code-Switching

Code-Switching

  • describes the ability of a speaker to 'switch' between different language varieties in his/her language use, often w/ other individuals that are able to do this + have shared experiences of several diff language forms
  • can take place across the whole range of accent + dialect forms

Sebba

  • London Jamaican - speakers of this are able to incorporate SE, RP, Jamaican Creole + Cockney forms in their language use
  • The environment in which this takes place means that some speakers, usually young, will have to adapt to a world in which they encounter many language forms
  • From this is, it is easy to see how London Jamaican or MEYD (Fox) emerges + how this skill enables speakers to deal w/ complexities of their language community
  • Sebba is keen to point out the sophistication of language use + the highly-skilled manipulation of language involved opposed to criticisms that levelled new forms as being 'dumbed down'
8 of 11

Sociolinguistic Maturation

Sociolinguistic Maturation

  • the age at which a speaker becomes far elss susceptibnle to influence of diff varieties of language on their own usage
  • no set age; most results suggest it 'sets in' around late teens to early twenties, after whicvh an adult speaker is much less likely to significantly alter their accent/dialect patterns due to any new strong sociolinguistic factor i.e. moving to another part of the UK
  • children before reaching this are much more likley to modify + vary usage

Researchers

  • Sebba - older family members not merging w/ London + English speech forms anywhere near same level as young girls resulting in the girls able to employ techniques ie. code-switching + form new varieties ie. London Jamaican, by becoming main promoters of change
9 of 11

Sociolinguistic Matuation Cont.

Kerswill

  • In Milton Keynes, he found that older caregivers + parents of children had not had their speech modified by features of new MK dialect emerging
  • Youngest children exhibited patterns of speech similar to caregivers perhaps showing that most language forms experienced were within the home + from caregivers
  • Older girls in mid-teens showed strongest incidence of emerging MK dialect; they were being shaped by the koneisation + were shaping new speech community + form
  • Fox and Kerswill's research in MEYD also hypothesised about the future of such youth dialects + whether they will be carried into adulthood by speakers
10 of 11

William Labov

Macy's vs. S.Klein - 1966

  • Labov looked into the way people alter their language depending on where they are; he looked at this on a fairly basic level of how workers talk depending on what shop they are in
  • Studying people in S.Klein he found that people spoke a more common form of AE, more typical of SE
  • Those in Saks and Macys, considered more upper-class were found to alter their language much more, making it more similar to a form of American RP
  • Labov denoted this to the perceived prestige attributed to  each place resulting in the need for the accent to "improve" as the shop's status increased
11 of 11

Comments

No comments have yet been made

Similar English Language resources:

See all English Language resources »See all Language variation and discourses resources »