The Teleological Argument (against)

HideShow resource information
View mindmap
  • Teleological criticisms
    • Hume
      • Although Hume wrote several years before Paley, his criticisms can still apply
      • WEAK ANALOGY = his strongest argument - comparing God the creator to anything on earth is not valid
      • SIMILAR EFFECTS = similar effects do not imply similar causes and we cannot assume there is a designers because we would have to have experienced to origin of the universe
      • Things appear to work together but it could all be chance
      • The world does not resemble something man-made
    • Darwin
      • His book 'origin of the species' goes against this and questioned beliefs about God through reason
      • THEORY OF NATURAL SELECTION = plants and animals change and adapt to their environment, and those who failed did not survive
      • Change had come about gradually through chance and it is simply survival of the fittest
      • Scientific evidence to back up Hume
    • Mill
      • If the world is designed by a loving God, then why is nature so cruel?
      • Problem of evil =an all-good God cannot be responsible for the evident evil
      • If process comes through pain and suffering, what does it say about the nature of the designer?
    • General criticisms
      • Flew argued that Aquinas' claim that things are directed goes against evidence we see today
      • Some argue that the world is just the way it is and doesnt need purpose
      • Aquinas assumes things have a purpose and goal but never gives evidence to back up
      • Humans don't have proper knowledge to assume
      • Paley's analogy would suggest that it is possible to believe more than one god created the world as there is more than one watchmaker

Comments

No comments have yet been made

Similar Religious Studies resources:

See all Religious Studies resources »See all Philosophy resources »