Science and Belief

HideShow resource information

Scientific Method


  • Belief that the world is orderly and intelligible and that evidence and experiment are the means to acquire knowledge. 
  • Desires to challenge and evaluate all claims to truth.

Formal system

  • Observation - Observing and gathering data on something in nature.
  • Hypothesis - Making an educated guess to explain the gathered data.
  • Experiment - Testing the hypothesis in controlled conditions. Confirm or falsify. 
  • Verification - Repeat. The more times the more accurate.

This is based on inductive reasoning and is not complete proof.

1 of 10

Scientific Method - Strengths

  • Bertrand Russel on scientist - 'his beliefs are tentative; they are not dogmatic; they are based on evidence, not on authority or intuition. 
  • Inductive Reasoning - although it cannot prove, it can be made highly likely.
  • Popper's falsification - can be constantly updated through time.
  • Objective - "truth is scientific truth" - Dawkins.
2 of 10


  • Meaning - God revealing himself and his meaning to earth.
  • Natural - Learning about God throgh his own creation. Eg. size of earth shows his power.
  • Special - God revealing himself to a specific person/people at a specific time. 
  • Decisive - Jesus is the decisive revelation as he is God's human form.
3 of 10


  • Fundamentalism, creationism
  • Bible is infallible - claims to truth. It's word is absolute and cannot be challenged.
  • Genesis 1 - earth created in 6 24 hour periods. John Ussher says the earth is 6000 years old.
4 of 10

Origin of Human Life - Scripture

Genesis 1

  • Man and woman created at the same time - 1 v 27, "man was created in God's image".
  • Pinnacle of God's creation - stewardship 1 v 31, "very good".

Genesis 2

  • Man was created first and he named the creatures.
  • Woman was created from man's rib.
5 of 10

Evidence Supporting Evolution

  • DNA/Genetics - Our DNA can be monitored to be shown it has changed/evolved over time.
  • Geology - Layers of strata can show how long the earth dates back.
  • Fossils - Fossils can show that humans weren't around the same time as dinosaurs therefore humans have evolved.
  • Natural selection in action - Darwin's finches and their different beaks.
  • Similarities with animals - eg. tailbone.
6 of 10

Christian Responses to Objection by Evolution


  • Catechism of catholic church - Led to greater admiration of creator, supported by the fact that he's created a longer universe.
  • St. Augustine - The bible is not meant to be read literally.
  • Wittgenstein - Language games. Migliore said science suggests how and belief suggests why.

Partially Successful

  • Anthropic priciple - Evolution can only take place in a habitable universe.
  • Tennent - Man possesses aesthetic awareness.
  • Temple - If we all followed survival of the fittest, there would be no morality.
  • Evolution is God's mechanism (this challenges an all powerful/loving God.)


  • Evolution is only a theory - it cannot be proved despite it being likely 
  • John Polkinghorne - God and providence. "flexibility of the process".
7 of 10

Paley's Design Argument/Teleo


  • Analogy - Paley compares a pocket watch to complex and purposeful mechanisms in nature. Because the pocket watch is designed and purposeful, so too are the natural mechanisms.


  • Comparison - The watch is complex and purposeful. It is a product of intellignet design. Nature has complex and purposeful mechanisms. Therefore they also have an intelligent designer.


  • Proportionality - Natural mechanisms are much more complicated than man-made mechanisms. Therefore designer of the natural mechanisms is much more powerful and intelligent than that of the watch. This designer is God.


  • Chance - Unlikely for complex and purposeful mechanisms to come about by chance. Even more unlikely for a more complex, natural mechanism to come about by chance


  • Regularity - Swinburne suggests that regularity points to order, and therefore a designer.
8 of 10

Teleological Criticisms


  • Hume - Universe could've come about by chance. In infinite time, particle matter could've randomly created a functioning universe.


  • Evolution - Paley wrote before Darwin. Evolution provides a much more compelling alternative than species being created to suit their environment.


  • Evolution variation - Evolution explains why species seem so expertly adapted to their environment


  • Steve Jones - There is no purpose to life, evolution is completely natural explanation.
9 of 10

Evidence Supporting BBT - unfinished

Edwin Hubble - redshift shows that stars are moving away from us which shows that the universe is expanding. Universe expanded from the Big Bang.

Background Radiation - we can still detect radiation that supports an explosion of that size eg. static in TVs.

10 of 10


No comments have yet been made

Similar Religious, Moral and Philosophical Studies resources:

See all Religious, Moral and Philosophical Studies resources »See all Science and Belief resources »