Regionalism

  • Created by: KDallers-
  • Created on: 15-05-19 19:51

Intro to Regionalism - What is it?

Viewed as a RESPONSE to globalisation - challenging the issues presented by globalisation; seen as a 'way out' of the negatives, while maintaining most of the benefits; INCREASING - 267 regional organisations in February 2016 (including ASEAN, EU, AU, MERCOSUR) - challenges realism

- Regionalisation defined by Harrell as "the growth of social integration within a region... and of social and economic integration" - this is what REGIONALISM is all about

- COOPERATION AND INTEGRATION - integration is about CHANGING domestic rules, whereas cooperation is more about harmonisation between 2 nations - regionalism offers a COMBINATION, involving pooling of sovereignty and delegating to supranational bodies in some instances (Moravscik)

- HISTORY - Europe post-WW2 sought regional integration following the failure of the League of Nations and UN - looked for 'ever closer union' to stand up to the US and USSR - becoming more multilateral through supranational government - has developed over time

- 'NEW REGIONALISM' - Telo - shows a need for deeper integration following Cold War in a multilateral society; can respond to crises effectively - DOESN'T mean SUPRANATIONALISM - Nordic common market in the 1950s, for example

1 of 8

EU as an Example of Regionalism

Challenging bipolarity of the US and USSR without taking a side - trying to introduce multipolarity/'tripolarity' - seeking peace and cooperation through a post-war consensus - started with 1951 Steel and Coal Committee and EFTA, and has increased constantly with SEA in 1980s, Maastricht Treaty, Nice Treaty, Lisbon Treaty - now looking towards 'federal structure'

- INSTITUTIONS: - Commission (bureaucracy and spitzenkandidaten), - Council, - Parliament and many others seeking to balance DEMOCRACY, SOVEREIGNTY, AND EFFICIENCY

- VIEW OF EU - Puchala - 'a blind man leading elephants' - about the pooling of sovereignty, and depoliticising nationally to facilitate economic cooperation - loss of sovereignty?

- ISSUES - Eurozone crisis - what should the EU be doing? Sense of 'contagion' across EU from Ireland, Portugal, Greece - Orban/Salvini/nationalists believe EU should work differently to how Merkel/Macron see this - decision of the EU have MAJOR REGIONAL REPERCUSSIONS

IS THE EU DEMOCRATIC? YES: - Parliament is elected, - member states can discuss, - output legitimacy (democratic output); NO: - Commission unelected, - German hegemony, - input legitimacy (Commission and lack of elections)

2 of 8

Worldwide Regionalism

AMERICAS - issue of Latin America vs the USA

- The O.A.S fell apart, leading to North American NAFTA 1986, and Latin American MERCOSUR 1991, with C.A.N 1997 - very little regional integration between North and South

AFRICA - based on anti-colonialism and REGIONS OF AFRICA

- Western, ex-French colonies formed WAEMU, Central CEMAC (monetary union pegged to Euro), Southern SACU (pegged to Rand), and a 2010 Eastern COMMON MARKET; less supranationalism, due to cultural divide (Arab North - AMU) - African Union have a peacekeeping role across the continent - in Somalia for example

ASIA - about relations with the US and Russia - South Asia and East Asia

- Eastern - ASEAN - formed for SECURITY PURPOSES 1967 - has done a moderately good job, given national and cultural divides within - became more ECONOMIC in 1992 - FTA - however, trying to promote stability still; US vs China - APEC vs TPP - which organisation will win? TPP yet to be ratified

CIS - issues of the zones of influence, especially in Ukraine - pro-EU or pro-Russia?

3 of 8

What do Regional Bodies do?

4 key functions: - MANAGEMENT OF INDEPENDENCE (consolidating identities of smaller, independent states through pooling of sovereignty), - MANAGEMENT OF INTERDEPENDENCE (creating security communities and promoting formal integration), - MANAGEMENT OF INTERNATIONALISATION (giving weight to multinational bodies for orderly internationalisation), and GEOPOLITICS (trying to break existing geopolitical divides, and organising those that remain)

- REGIONALIST POLITICS - often creates a 'domino effect', as regional bodies respond to one another - trying to develop through cooperation (such as ASEAN), however regional bodies do COMPETE with each other; pooling sovereignty, but still trying to give individual states a say

Regional bodies offer RESPONSES TO CRISES: such as the GFC 2008 (EU response) and the Eurozone crisis (for example, bailouts for Greece)

- REGIONAL BODIES WORK TO BALANCE INTERNATIONAL INTEGRATION WITH TERRITORIAL SOVEREIGNTY - A MIDDLE ROAD OF GLOBALISATION

4 of 8

Regionalism and Globalisation

Regionalism seeks to provide a step between national and global in terms of governance

- Trade agreements within regional bodies can CONSTRAIN states and encourage COMPETITION - a balance between the 'trilemma' of globalisation?

- Offers CULTURAL COHESION - states can forge new relationships through COMMON GROUND developed within regional bodies - based on values - WESTERN LIBERAL VALUES = EU BONDING; however, not so possible in ASEAN due to CULTURAL DIVIDES

- Regionalism encourages 'collective action' and coming together in a multipolar world - protecting sovereignty, but encouraging economic integration

DANI RODRIK - there is potential for 'perfect integration', but this is unlikely to happen due to borders, languages, exchange rates; investment - people invest in their own nations if they are ADVANCED ECONOMIES, and transaction costs and foreign contracts pose issues for INTERNATIONAL ECONOMIC INTEGRATION

- Regionalism acts as a response to these issues - globalisation in a more broken-up manner

5 of 8

Rodrik's Trilemma

Based on Obstfeld and Taylor's original MACROECONOMIC TRILEMMA; adapts this to a 'political trilemma of globalisation; - 3 key areas: NATION-STATE, INTERNATIONAL ECONOMIC INTEGRATION, MASS POLITICS - can only have 2 - all three are incompatible

- INTEGRATION-POLITICS - federalism - a global federalist system would be needed if mass politics and integration were to be retained; the nation-state would be sacrificed - much like the USA, or EU route towards a 'United States of Europe' - removes barriers for integration

- INTEGRATION-NATION-STATE - Friedman's 'Golden Straitjacket' - retains sovereignty and promotes integration, but narrows political options due to SUPRANATIONALISM - "YOUR ECONOMY GROWS, YOUR POLITICS SHRINKS"

- POLITICS-NATION-STATE - Bretton-Woods - leads to trade liberalisation and less border restrictions, but not to the extent that integration can occur - only cooperation - worked until the 1980s, then splintered into European integration, Japanese capitalism and growth in the Third World

6 of 8

Strengths, Criticisms and Future of Regionalism

STRENGTHS: - allows the state to pursue the national interest; - beneficial for small states (can pool sovereignty and exercise the benefits of multilateralism); - promotes socioeconomic benefits and liberalisation - BHAGURATI

CRITICISMS: - reduction of territorial sovereignty if leaning towards federalism; - constraints placed on states (new supranational bodies and rules to adhere to); - entrenches inequality (in a similar manner to globalisation), - POSTCOLONIALISM - regionalism REIFIES colonial perspectives, as powerful states dominate and become more powerful - such as the EU and CAP exploiting POORER FARMERS

FUTURE: Rodrik - believes in federalism with global authorities, officials, elections and more INNOVATIVE forms of governance

- This will occur due to technological advancements, maintanence of citizenship, and looking toward the WORLD MARKET for prosperity

- SOUNDS REMARKABLY LIKE THE WAY THE EU IS GOING

7 of 8

Key Thinkers of Regionalism

Rodrik - trilemma, future of regionalism

Best and Christensen - examples of African, American, African regionalism

Harrell - definition of 'regionalisation'

Moravscik - concept of supranationalism

Telo - 'new regionalism' post-Cold War

Puchala - EU being 'blind man leading an elephant'

Obstfeld and Taylor - original macroeconomic trilemma

Friedman - 'Golden Straitjacket'

Bhagurati - the strengths/weaknesses of regionalism

8 of 8

Comments

No comments have yet been made

Similar Government & Politics resources:

See all Government & Politics resources »See all Regionalism resources »