Do any other sources support Aristotles critiscism of the EPHORATE

looking for support from other sources on Aristotle's critiscm  on the ephorate

Aristotle critism of the Ephorate vs other sources

Aristotle:

  • 5 member are chosen from among all the people  so men not well off find themselves  holding office;  lack of money = open to bribery
  • 
  • No other sources support this

Aristotle:

  •  The power of the ephors is excesssive and dictatorial
  • 

 Xenophon VIII 3/4

  • Ephors have the right to punish at will, fine, depose of magistrates. Don't often allow office holders to complete their year of office.
1 of 3

Aristotle critism of the Ephorate vs other sources

Aristotle:

  • Spartan kings have been forced to curry power with them

Plutarch:

  • Theyb acted as a curb again excessive power of the King

Xenophon XV:

  • Ephors don't stand when the king enters, but stay seated on special thrones. They make an oath to follow the king as long as he follows the law.
  • 
2 of 3

Aristotle critism of the Ephorate vs other sources

Aristotle:

  • "present method of selection strikes me as childish"

Thucydides 85 - 87:

  • Same Ephor that make pro-war speech took the shouting vote and then made them stand on seperate sides. (Forcing segregation makes people more likely to go to the side with more people)

 Aristotle:

  • They should not have power to give verdicts on their own.
  • 

Xenophon VIII 3/4

  • Ephors have the right to punish at will.
  • 
3 of 3

Comments

No comments have yet been made

Similar Ancient History resources:

See all Ancient History resources »