1. We perceive something having some property F
2. When we perceive something having some property F then there is something that has this property
3. In an illusion, the physical object does not have the property F
4. Therefore, property F is something mental, a sense datum
5. Therefore, in illusions, we see sense data, not physical objects immediately
6. Illusions can be subjectively indistinguishable from veridical perception
7. Therefore, we see sense data in both illusions and veridical perception
8. Therefore, in all cases we see sense data, not physical objects, immediately
9. Therefore, direct realism is false
Comments
No comments have yet been made