Humanity is mostly determined but there are elements that can be argued to not be.
Thomas Hobbes (1588-1579), supporter of Soft Determinism. He argued that all human behaviours are determined, but there is a difference between the 2 types of causes: internal + external.
Internal = a choice made internally that is determined, e.g. whether I should hold the door open for my teacher.
External = someone is forced to do something against their pre-determined will, they are free from external causes, e.g. my pre-determined internal cause was that I wanted to hold the door open for my teacher, but then someone pushes me so that I cannot fulfil my pre-determined desire.
A.J. Ayer (1910-1989) also supported the concept by empirically studying the language differences between the theories. Ayer found that in soft determinism there is the internal cause of 'causing' an event, but there is no external cause.
Soft determinism = "caused", the moral agent will use the word 'caused' to describe being determined.
Hard determinism = "forced", the moral agent will use the word 'forced' to describe being determined.
Comments
No comments have yet been made