Court of Appeal à 2 Divisions both bound by House of Lords.
Civil – Only court which generally binds itself.
Young v Bristol Aeroplane 1944 à In this case, the COA declared that it would be bound by its own decisions, it also laid down the grounds on which it would not be bound by them;
ü Where two previous decisions of the COA conflicted the COA could choose which decision to follow. The other would then be overruled.
ü Where there was a later decision of the HOL which conflicted with a COA decision, the COA would follow the HOL decision.
ü Where a COA decision had been made per incuriam, that is, without taking into account a relevant case or Statute, then, the decision made in error can be overruled.
Criminal – Not bound itself since R v Gould 1968 and Liberty of individual too important.
Comments
Report