1642-49 From Civil War to Revolution

What motivated men to take sides?

  •     Traditional explanations:
  •     Royalists: north and west of England, less advanced economically
  •    Parliamentarians: London and south-east, wealthiest parts of country
  •    The Problem of Neutralism
  •   Vast majority of PN tried to avoid taking sides in the war
  •   Neutralism grew as war progressed
  •  1645 local gentry in 10 counties made Clubmen Associations
  •  Clubmen aimed at using military force to keep royalist & parliamentarian armies out of their counties
1 of 41

What motivated men to take sides?

  •  ROYALISTS
  •  Feared Parliaments attacks on King would lead to widespread social revolution & eventual anarchy
  •  Felt the established Church must be defended
  •  Feared religious radicalism had been released by Pym
  •  PARLIAMENTARIANS
  • Feared that King, misled by evil advisers had been making attempts to destroy Parliament and English liberties
  • Committed to reducing or abolishing bishops power
  •  Therefore, religion was a key factor
2 of 41

How did each side finance war?

  • ·      Both sides sometimes resorted to confiscation of opponent’s property and stealing
  • ·      ROYALISTS
  • ·      Charles reliant on gifts from wealthy royalists
  • ·      Royalists eventually copied parliamentary methods but less successful
  • ·      Often relied on Free Quarter- taking of good promising owners would be compensated
3 of 41

How did each side finance war?

  • ·      PARLIAMENT
  • ·      Monthly assessment: direct tax on income and wealth
  • ·      Excise tax: tax on range of goods including beer and wine
  • ·      End of 1640s MA collecting £90,000 a month
  • ·      Gentry eventually supported Parliament as their army was better and more regularly paid
  • ·      Meant were less likely to resort to plunder
  • ·      However 1645 growing discontent among parliamentary supporters about crushing      taxation that PN was now paying
  • ·      Parliament set up County Committees to supervise collection of taxation
  • ·      These became hated as local gentry saw them as “social upstarts”
4 of 41

Consequences: Parliaments financial

Consequences: Parliament's financial organisation

  • ·      Had some negative effects on Parliament
  • ·      Both sides of PN desperate to end taxation of war
  • ·      Also concerned at how County Committees had destroyed local independence of gentry
  • ·      PN desperate for a speedy settlement that would restore normality
  • ·      PN also desperate to disband NMA
  • ·      Fears of growing religious and political radicalism in NMA was even more vital that it be disbanded quickly
5 of 41

Was Parliamentary victory always inevitable


  •  
  • ·      Factors that allowed Parliament to win:
  • ·      Greater finances
  • ·      Control of London and SE England
  • ·      London centre of printing- easier to produce propaganda
  • ·      Control of navy: prevented Charles receiving supplies from Ireland
  • ·      Alliance with Scots Covenanters
  • ·      Weakness in royalist leadership
  • ·      Parliamentary became more likely during war but WASN’T inevitable until 1645
  • ·      June 1645: King’s main army destroyed at NAESBY
6 of 41

Search for Allies

  • ·      Royalist attempts:
  • ·      Sept 1643: Charles signed CESSATION with Irish Rebels, Irish troops would come and fight on royalist side
  • ·      This was propaganda disaster for Charles when made public
  • ·      Troops of little use
  • ·      Parliamentary attempts:
  • ·      Sept 1643: Parliament signed alliance with Scots Covenanters
  • ·      Scots would provide army of 21,000
  • ·      Pym also established COMMITTEE OF BOTH KINGDOMS to coordinate finance & fighting of war

·       

7 of 41

Civil War in Scotland & Ireland

  • CIVIL WAR IN SCOTLAND
  • Not all Scottish nobles were Covenanters
  • Earl of Montrose led royalist forces against Covenanters in Scotland & won no. of battles
  • Sept 1645: Battle of Philiphaugh: Covenanter army crushed Montrose's forces
  • Ended Charles' military hopes in Scotland
  • CIVIL WAR IN IRELAND
  • Outbreak of Irish Rebellion made civil war more complicated through religion
  • War in Ireland particularly brutal
  • 1642: Catholic rebels formed Confederation: now known as confederates
  • Opponents were Protestants of Ulster commanded by Earl of Ormond
  • Sept 1643: Ormond signed 1 year truce under Charles' order allowing Irish troops to fight for King
  • Troops had little impact
  • Reinforced that Charles was sympathetic to Catholics
  • Sept 1646: Confederate army defeated Covenanters giving Confederates back control of Ireland
  • By 1646 Confederates unwilling to give further help to Charles
8 of 41

Parliamentary Leadership

How important was Parliamentary leadership in winning war?

  • Charles was poor war leader, allowed quarrels to develop that obstructed war effort
  • E.g. poor leadership: Battle of Edgehill Oct 1642
  • Didn't take opportunity to take London after Parliamentary forces retreated
  • However Parliamentary leadership just as split
9 of 41

Tension & Division Parliament

By 1643

  • "Peace Group"- wanted settlement, unhappy seeing King humiliated
  • "War Group"- felt King must be defeated in war & have harsh conditions imposed
  • Dec 1643: death of Pym deprived Parliament of leadership
  • Splits became more intense
  • 1644: Battle of Marston Moor: Parliamentary victory meant Charles lost control of northern England
  • HOWEVER
  • "War party" in Parliament appointed military leaders based on social status
  • EARL OF ESSEX & EARL OF MANCHESTER
  • 1644: Essex's entire force captured
  • 1644: Manchester allowed royalist army to withdraw even though near victory
  • End 1644: peace negotiations failed as Charles confident he might win
10 of 41

Events to Parliamentary Victory

  • Feb 1645: NMA Ordinance
  • Parliamentary Army of 21,000
  • Commanded by Thomas Fairfax
  • April 1645: Self-denying ordinance
  • All MPs to give up military commands
  • Get rid of incompetent commanders (Essex & Manchester)
  • Now general determination among MPs to end war
  • KEY FACTOR IN PARLIAMENTARY VICTORY
  • June 1645: Battle of Naesby: Charles' main army destroyed
  • Parliamentary victory now inevitable
  • May 1646: Charles surrenderd to Scots
  • Greatest concern among MPs now was radicalism of NMA
11 of 41

Search for Settlement 46-47

  • July 1646: Charles presented with NEWCASTLE PROPOSITIONS
  • Included: Triennial Parliaments
  • Parliament nominate King's chief ministers
  • Parliament to control militia
  • Anglicanism abolished, no toleration
  • Majority of PN desperate for permanent settlement 
  • Would return to traditional government
  • Overwhelming fears of radicalism in NMA
  • MPs and gentry want to disband army ASAP
  • Thought permanent settlement was inevitable 1646-47
12 of 41

Role of King 1646-47

  • Charles had no intention of giving up powers
  • Saw all enemies of traitors
  • Felt he lost war because he gave up divine powers
  • Knew enemies were deeply divided
  • Didn't want to accept Newcastle Propositions- logic to this
  • Charles seemed to be being proved right
13 of 41

Development radicalism NMA

How did religious radicalism develop in NMA?

  • 1640s breakdown of religious censorship as quarrel between King and PN resulted in collapse of authority
  • Breakdown allowed radical groups to expand
  • Majority of NMA just wanted pay arrears and indemnity
  • Cavalry were more educated: 
  • Felt their lives had been changed by army experience
  • NMA had defeated King- believed they were an "instrument of God"
  • Saw themselves as "army of Saints"
  • "Independent" beliefs grew among many soldiers
  • Prepared to accept national church but each congregation to decide on own form of worship
  • Cromwell increasingly seen as spokesman of Independent religious sects
  • REACTION OF MPs
  • Horrified at developments in Army
  • "Gangraena"- document about religious extremism in army revealed fears of MPs and PN
14 of 41

Cromwell's Role

  • By 1645: Cromwell incresingly attacked by Parliament for promotion of soldiers with radical religious views
  • He was an "old style puritan"
  • Believed "godliness" could be found in all religious radical groups
  • Believed England could be a godly nation
  • POLICY OF PROMOTION BY MERIT
  • Attacked social hierarchy
  • Horrified MPs
  • One hand he was social & political "conservative"- wanted return to traditional forms of government 
  • Other hand wanted some form of religious liberty for radical groups & to eventually create "godly" nation
15 of 41

1646 Divisions in Parliament

"POLITICAL PRESBYTERIANS"

  • Wanted speedy settlement with King
  • Wanted national Presbyterian Church settlement
  • Feared growing radicalism in Army
  • Aimed to Disband Army

"POLITICAL INDEPENDENTS"

  • Wanted strict conditions imposed on King
  • Accept state church but should be some external liberty of worship
  • Close links w/Army- only they could guarentee their demands

"LEVELLERS & POLITICAL RADICALISM"

  • Based in London, John Lilburne & Richard Overton
  • Existing forms of government should be replaced with more democratic system
  • Belief all men are born equal
16 of 41

Politicalisation of Army

Why did the Army emerge as a Political Force?

  • Blame lies with Political Presbyterian MPs
  • Assumed they could disband NMA with no pay arrears
  • Insult to honour of Army
  • Several petitions sent by army w/ help of Cromwell to Parliament
  • Majority of demands were material (pay arrears)
  • Owed £3m in arrears
  • Would've settled for less
  • DID NOT SEEM LIKE THEY WOULD EXPLODE INTO REVOLUTIONARY ACTION
  • REACTION OF POLITICAL PRESBYTERIANS IN PARLIAMENT
  • March 1647: Parliament issued "Declaration of Dislike"
  • Ordered NMA to disband at once
  • No indemnity offered
  • PP began attempt to raise new army led by Presbyterian officers
  • They overreacted to moderate demands of Army
17 of 41

Result

  • May 1647: MPs voted to disband the Army with 8 weeks pay arrears
  • Too late- Army felt it's honour had been insulted
  • Attack on Army by PP turned them into political force
  • May 1647: Army issued "SOLEMN ENGAGEMENT" -refused to disband until grievances listened to
  • June 1647: "Declaration of Army"- set out its political demands
  • Regular parliaments, religious liberty
  • Punishment of leading PP's
  • References to "free-born Englishmen" Influence of Levellers?
  • July 1647
  • Army occupied London, PP leaders fled
  • Army emerged as dominant political force
  • Made settlement more difficult
18 of 41

Cromwell's Role Politicalisation NMA

What was Cromwell's role in politicalisation of Army?

  • He was torn between his two instincts
  • Natural political "conservative"- deeply concerned about radicalism in Army going out of control & didn't want any major changes to society
  • Religious radicalism- he wanted to see religious liberty established and believed Army was an "instrument of God"
  • He felt unless he took control of demands radicalism would go out of control
  • This is why he agreed to capture the King 
  • Cromwell and his son in law HENRY IRETON seen as main spokesmen of Army
19 of 41

Heads of Proposals

June 1647

  • These were drawn up by Ireton 
  • Parliament would nominate King's advisers for 10 years
  • Bishops remain in national church but lose power to force attendance at Church
  • Biennial Parliaments
  • Some Leveller grievances would be redressed
  • Charles would remain at heart of government, Anglican Church would remain
  • They reveal Ireton & Cromwell's desire to return to traditional forms of government 
  • Charles has been criticised for not accepting these
  • He didn't realise only the Army could enforce a settlement
  • He began to play Army off against Parliament
  • It was Charles betryal of Army 1647-48 that cost him his life
  • Charles believed he had more power than he actually did 
  • He had a "lack of political reality"
20 of 41

Splits in Army 1647

By October 1647

  • Junior officers becoming disillusioned with lack of progress in final settlement
  • Junior officers wanted wide range of reforms
  • Growing suspicisons among this group that Cromwell & Ireton were pursuing selfish motives
  • These feelings were exploited by the Levellers
  • Levellers & Leveller propoganda began to infiltrate lower ranks of army
  • Oct 1647: THE CASE OF THE ARMY TRULY STATED
  • Produced by Levellers
  • Attack on Army grandees for not pushing for radical political reforms
  • How did Cromwell & Ireton react?
  • Increasingly concerned about the demands of some agitators & their leveller allies
  • However trying to crush Leveller influence in Army might provoke a mutiny agaisnt senior officers
  • Conviced Charles even more that his enemies were falling apart
21 of 41

Agreement of the People Oct 1647

  • This was Levellers blueprint for a future settlement
  • All men born equal
  • Complete freedom of worship
  • No mention of role of King or House of Lords, basically arguing for a democratic republic
  • Levellers began a campaign in Army to have agreement accepted as plan for future settlement
  • Cromwell & Ireton increasing fear of Army Mutiny
22 of 41

Putney Debates

Oct-Nov 1647

  • Cromwell desperate to maintain Army unity
  • Cromwell had no intention of accepting the agreement but during debates he emphasised that both sides could find common ground
  • He spoke little in the debates Ireton was left to defend the grandees against agitators
  • Most arguments based around Ireton & the agitators on the franchise 
  • Ireton argued it must be based on ownership of property
  • Some Levellers pushed for full adult male franchise
  • Others argued men recieving charity should be excluded
  • Reveals key weakness of Levellers- unable to agree on a common programme
  • Opposing views of agitators & grandees couldn't be reconciled
  • Putney debates ended as Cromwell realised not much more could be gained and Charles actually escaped from Army control November 1647
23 of 41

The Second Civil War

24 December 1647: PP MPs presented Charles with 4 Bills

  • Immediately rejected by Charles
  • Charles instead signed an "Engagement" with Scots Covenanters
  • This would:
  • Introduce Presbyterian Church as national church in England 3 years
  • Charles provided with army of 20,000
  • Scots did realise however that Charles' promises were worthless
  • Would now be difficult for Charles to appeal to English supporters as a defender of Anglican Church
  • January 1648: Parliament pass "VOTE OF NO ADDRESSES"- all negotiations with King to be broken off
  • Charles had temporarily reunited Parliament and the Army against him
  • Many MPs were horrified by King's actions, knew Charles was planning a series of royalist risings
24 of 41

Second Civil War 1648

  • Why was there no negotiated settlement 1646-1647?
  • 1. Terms offered to Charles unacceptable to him
  • Not prepared to give up prerogative rights
  • Felt he made enough concessions 1641
  • 2. Charles aware there was growing resentment throughout nation at "parliamentary tyranny"
  • Hatred of monthly assessment/excise taxes
  • Hatred of County committes
  • Hatred of Army
  • 3. Little agreement among vicors of 1646 about peace terms
  • Fully Presbyterian Church would've pleased most MPs but not the Political Independent MPs or Army
25 of 41

Events of 2nd Civil War 48

  • Charles cut off from political and military realities
  • Could only see the divisions of his enemies
  • Many Covenanters unhappy that he refused to sign the Covenant 
  • NMA discipline had been reasserted
  • Most of PN wanted settlement, didn't necessarily support King's actions
  • June 1648: Scots Army invaded N.England
  • August 1648: Battle of Preston
  • NMA crushed Scots Covenanter Army 
  • This ended the Second Civil War
  • BUT: August 1648- Vote of no addresses overturned in Parliament
  • MPs aware that hatred & fear of NMA, high taxation and religious radicalism were far more important than distrust of the King
26 of 41

Events of 2nd Civil War 48

  • Sept 1648: Parliament began negotating with King at Newport (Newport Negotiations)
  • Evidence suggests they might have been near to agreement
  • But Charles refused to abandon the Prayer Book for a "Directory of Worship"
  • Charles made comments about no being bound to a mock treaty
  • Could have been planning to decieve them again?
  • Many prominent Political Independent MPs now prepared to deal with the King- becoming concerned with rumours of radicalism in Army
  • THEREFORE superficially the prospects of a settlement looked closer than ever
  • But for Cromwell and Ireton this was the moment of truth- attitudes had changed
27 of 41

English Revolution 1648-49

  • Army leaders began to support some of the views of ordinary soldiers
  • Republicanism became serious political solution
  • May 1648: At a "godly prayer meeting" there was a promise to bring Charles to account for his crimes
  • At first Cromwell didn't play a big part as he was fighting in 2nd Civil War
  • Fairfax refused to become more politically involved
  • The main instigator of events over the next few months would be Ireton
28 of 41

48-49 The Regicide & Revolution

  • 20th Nov 1648: Remonstrance of Army
  • Presented to Parliament, demanded King be brought to justice
  • 6th Dec 1648: Prides Purge
  • Colonel Thomas Pride with 1000 NMA soldiers surrounds Parliament buildings
  • 45 MPs arrested, 186 secluded, 86 withdrew in protest, 80 stayed away
  • Only 71 MPs left to bring King to justice "RUMP"
  • 6th Jan 1649: "Rump Parliament" establishes High Court Of Justice to try King for high treason against people of England
  • 30th Jan: CHARLES IS EXECUTED
  • March: Act abolishing monarchy and House of Lords is passed
  • May: Rump declares England to be a Commonwealth
29 of 41

Why demand death of King?

Why did the Army demand the death of the King?

  • Atttidues of most MPs by late 1648?
  • "Conservative" case for compromise strengthened
  • Rebellions revealed popular hatred of parliaments attempts to reform religion
  • This is why PP's in Parliament took lead in restarting negotiations with King
  • Also explains why Vote of No Addresses was repealed and why NMA's REMONSTRANCE was rejected
  • Even some Political Independent MPs agreed to restart negotiations- many concerned about the rumours of radicalism in NMA about bringing King to justice
  • The Army and "Providence" by late 1648
  • Here politicalisation of NMA reached its logical conclusion
  • Charles' negotiations with Scots and secret Engagement proved he couldn't be trusted
  • Therefore pointless to negotiate as he couldn't maintain any agreement 
  • The Army claimed he had forfeited his right to be regarded as God's anointed
  • By rejecting God's verdict in the 1st Civil War he had rejected God himself
30 of 41

NMA's Remonstrance Nov 1648

  • Drawn up by Ireton who played lead in bringing King to trial
  • Even Ireton was unsure about what to do with the King if he was put on trial
  • There was no mention of the abolition of the monarchy
  • PRIDE'S PURGE DEC 1648
  • After the Purge only 71 MPs were left to carry out the will of the Army
  • At this point it was unclear what would happen next
  • Cromwelll still tried to persuade the King to make concessions but he refused 
  • Cromwell intrepreted this as PROVIDENTIAL sign he had been waiting for
  • He now pushed for a public trial, Charles must be found guilty and executed as imprisonment would leave him to plot
  • However no one was really sure of what to do after Charles was dead
  • It was 2 months after his execution that the step was taken to abolish the monarchy and establish the republican Commonwealth
  • Seems main reason for abolition of monarchy was lack of suitable replacement for Charles
31 of 41

The Trial

  • Rump establushed High Court of Justice to try the King, House of Lords objected 
  • Rump said it could pass laws without them
  • Charles refused to recognise the Court for a week and was sentenced to death for "drivers and high crimes and treasons"
  • Only 59 commissioners signed the death warrant- may have been forced to by Cromwell & Ireton
32 of 41

The "English Revolution"

  • No hint of any mass popular enthusiasm for English Revolution
  • Charles was actually more popular at the time of his death than any other
  • Day before Prides Purge most MPs said negotiations with King should continue 
  • Key feature of Revolution is that it was carried out by a minority 
  • By late 1648 Cromwell and Ireton felt there was no option other than to execute the monarchy
  • Why was he executed?
  • Much of the blame lies with Charles himself 
  • Emergence of radicals especially in Army was major factor
  • Two key factors were NECESSITY and PROVIDENCE
  • Necessity: Distrust of the King and lack of any alternative settlement 
  • Charles would never agree to any kind of settlement 
  • An agreement with Charles was impossible and there was no alternative
  • Providence: To Army victory in war had been decided by God's judgement 
  • By restarting war Charles had mocked God's judgement therefore he was a man of blood
  • This was what drove men like Cromwell
33 of 41

Radical Groups Late 1640s

  • Levellers
  • Most important group to appear during Revolution
  • John Lilburne, John Wildman, William Walwyn and Richard Overton
  • They began to publish a stream of pamphlets
  • In autumn 1647 they collaborated with militant army agitators producing "THE CASE OF THE ARMY TRULY STATED" and the first "AGREEMENT OF THE PEOPLE"
  • They played a major part in the Putney debates
  • Cromwell and Ireton feared that if they ignored them it might lead to an army mutiny
  • HOWEVER: Cromwell aware ordinary soldiers support for Levellers depended whether they got paid or not
  • Cromwell also aware that it was fear of Levellers that was dangerous 
  • When an army mutiny happened it was easily crushed: shows Leveller's impact was more exaggerated
34 of 41

The Whitehall Debates

  • 14th Dec 1648- 13 Jan 1649
  • Ireton and Cromwell probably allowed these debates to take place as they wanted to ensure army unity as the trial of King was about to take place
  • Levellers had drawn up "AGREEMENT OF THE PEOPLE"
  • They hoped Rump would accept it and dissolve itself so more democratic elections were held
  • When it was obvious Rump wouldn't carry out reforms Levellers felt betrayed
  • Leveller's anger mainly directed against Cromwell and they wrote more pamphlets
  • Feb 1649: Lilburne and Overton were arrested & sent to Tower of London
  • Still issued a third "AGREEMENT OF THE PEOPLE"
  • April/May 1649: Increasing discontent in Army over pay arrears 
  • Mutinies took place in Army but were easily crushed
  • After this little heard from Levellers again
  • Rump ensured Army had regular pay
35 of 41

What was "Leveller Cause"

  • Most common arguments between Levellers:
  • Existing political establishment should be replace with one 'agreed by the people'
  • All men equal and government was based on consent of people
  • Some wanted monarchy and House of Lords abolished
  • Complete religious toleration
  • All equal before the law
  • The most comprehensive and radical programme to appear during Revolution
36 of 41

The Diggers

  • Thought of themselves as the "True Levellers"
  • Followers of Gerald Winstanley
  • Attempted to set up communities that cultivated the land in common
  • First Digger Commun 1649 chased out by property owners
  • They were quickly destroyed by local opposition
37 of 41

Religious Millenarian Groups

  • The Fifth Monarchists
  • Most powerful of the Millenarian groups
  • In early years of Republic posed real threat to the state
  • Believed there would be 4 great earthly monarchies with fourth monarchy being reign of ANTICHRIST
  • After this King Jesus would return and end the world
  • They were influential in the Army, led by Colonel Thomas Harrison
  • He was most vocal senior officer in demanding death of King
38 of 41

Effect of religious & political

The Effect of the Radical Political and Religious Groups on the English Revolution

  • The Levellers
  • Their influence on NMA overall was small
  • Many soldiers who supported them were only concerned with getting their pay back
  • When they were paid Leveller influence died down
  • They didn't propose on giving the vote to women 
  • They rarely agreed on social/economic reforms
  • Little support was given to them
  • The Diggers
  • A small, insignificant minority of people
  • The Fifth Monarchists
  • Influenced Army's demand to try the King and execute him, had even greater influence 1653
39 of 41

Cromwell and radical

What was Cromwell's opinion of the radical groups?

  • Desired wide religious toleration especially for all Protestants who did not disturb public peace
  • Also assumed the fear of Levellers was greatly exaggerated
  • Wished to preserve hierarchy of society
  • This is why he was keen to persecute the Levellers
  • Fear they created smong gentry made his aim of achieving religious liberty more difficult
  • Also why throughout this period Cromwell was in a dilemma
  • Wanyed religious liberty and some reform but the PN exaggerated the threat of radicals & viewed any form of toleration as leading to chaos and anarchy
40 of 41

CONCLUSION

  • It was fear of radical groups that was important
  • None of them achieved more than a temporary, local popularity
  • Most important group were the Levellers but in many ways their influence was negative
  • Fear of Levellers encouraged the growth of "conservatism" throughout the period
  • Meant the PN became even more desperate for a return to traiditonal forms of government
41 of 41

Comments

No comments have yet been made

Similar History resources:

See all History resources »See all British monarchy - Tudors and Stuarts resources »