How successful were the Conservative governments of 1979 to 1997 in dealing with Britain's economic problems? [45 marks]

?

How successful were the Conservative governments of 1979 to 1997 in dealing with Britain's economic problems? [45 marks]

Advantages

  • Thatcher's monetarism relied on market forces and evened out old structural imbalance – particularly between manufacturing and the service sector.
  • The privatisation of major firms, e.g. British Aerospace (1981), British Telecom (1984), British Leyland (1984), Rolls-Royce (1987), and British Steel (1988) and the selling off of the gas, water and electricity industries provided ready cash and widened share ownership.
  • Deregulation led to the abolition of exchange controls, 1979. British assets abroad rose (£12 billion – £110 billion, 1979–1986). This was a record level and second only to Japan.
  • Thatcher signed the Single European Act (SEA), allowing for the free movement of goods within the EU – which increased competition and efficiency. Trade with Europe increased significantly.
  • From 1986, Britain experienced an economic boom with growth of over 4%; unemployment fell in 1989 and although it grew again in 1990, there was continued improvement.
  • Thatcher's taming of the unions – helping to make GB more competitive.
  • Kenneth Clarke’s work as Chancellor – recovery from the recession of the early 1990s and the new monetary policy after Black Wednesday (reducing the basic rate of income tax, government spending and reducing the budget deficit).

Disadvantages

  • Monetarism was detrimental to traditional manufacturing, and unemployment was particularly high in old manufacturing centres. (Nearly 20% in Northern Ireland and over 15% in many parts of Wales, Scotland and Northern England).
  • Thatcher's era was marked by fluctuating interest rates. Deflationary measures brought a rise in unemployment in the early 1980s (3 million in January 1982) and again in the early 1990s.
  • The tying of the British pound to EU exchange rates, as part of the Exchange Rate Mechanism (ERM) proved disastrous when restrictions imposed by the ERM put pressure on the pound, leading to a run on the currency. Black Wednesday in 1992 ended British membership of the ERM. It also damaged the credibility of the Conservatives' economic management, and contributed to the end of the 18 years of consecutive Conservative governments in 1997.
  • The inheritance of the winter of discontent in 1979 and battles with the unions which culminated in the Miners' Strike of 1984.
  • The performance of other countries suggested Britain was in economic decline.
  • The social impact of economic policies may be considered as an issue.

Evaluation

Comments

No comments have yet been made