Criticisms on Plato - A level

?
  • Created by: ariana123
  • Created on: 03-01-18 13:25

Disagree:

  • Absolutist- No concrete proof that either the world in the cave or outside the cave is real
  • Elitism in the cave and rejection of the posteriori
  • Plato suggests that philosophers are best placed to rule since they have greater knowledge, but they may overlook practical skills needed for ruling, by reliance on an intellectualist approach
  • Karl Popper- True reality is changeable
  • No proof/empirical evidence
  • is there a form of everything, Cancer?
  • Concepts of Beauty.Goodness may come from experience and upbringings
  • Aristotle- lack of empirical proof "no sense leads to non-sense"
  • Aristotle said he could not agree that the form of something has separate existence over and above the particular
  • 3rd man argument - the form of the form (infinite regress +nonsense)
  • R.Dawkind -> we are just DNA. Ideas/,atter are from evolution -> Not forms
  • Freud - the Psychological crutch. E.g. Comfort in life after death 

Comments

No comments have yet been made