Anthony Flew took this approach and used it for religious language. Flew claimed that if there was absoulutely no situation in which a religious person would abandon their beliefs as false, then any religious statement was meaningless. Flew gave an example of a gardener:
“Two explorers come across a clearing in a jungle. It contains a mixture of weeds and flowers. One claims that there must be a gardener who comes to tend the clearing. The other denies it. They sit and wait, but no gardener appears, however they try to detect him.” One gardener continues to claim that there is a gardener; one who is invisible, inaudible, intangible and undetectable.
Comments
No comments have yet been made