The 1848 Revolutions
- Created by: jojo10834
- Created on: 21-02-17 11:08
Transformation of Europe
- 18th Century Europe in a period of political and social Ferment
- Aided by industrial revolution which, in turn, led to urbanisation
- Long-term transformation
- Aftermath of 1789 - end of ancien regime
- The revolutions acted as a catalyst for the abolishment of Monarchy
Class Consciousness
- Central to 1848 revolutions, but complex
- Marxist formulation - historical change only happens where there is a clash between classes and their economic interests
- Marx: As industrialisation progresses, each class develops its own "consciousness"
- Middle classes - own "means of production" - working class consciousness centred by this
- Middle class = Mild reform
Working class = Revolution
Breakdown of traditional political control
- Industrialisation and population growth
- Clash between ancien regime and the growth of nationalism
- Elites aware of the power of the people
- France saw the restoration of the Bourbon monarchy: Louis Philippe
- France+Liberal State = seeds of destruction
- 1815-1830 Conservative ascendancy
Breakdown of traditional political control 2
- If uprisings are successful than the elites position is threatened
- 1815-1830 - Elites re-asserted themselves according to historians in this periodisation
New Forces: Liberalism
1. Attacking arbitrary authority - Government should be based on consensus
2. Advocating weakening of traditional institutions
3. Often associated with middle classes - part of progress
4. Wanted to strengthen power of parliament
5. Liberal discussions just intellectual debates?
New Forces: Democracy
- Universal adult suffrage - will of the people
- Abolition of monarchy and hereditary power
- Appeal to the urban working class
- Democratic politics/principles most developed in France
New Forces: Socialists
- Economic reform over political reform
- 1830s - still infancy as an ideology
- Common ownership of the means of production
- Politically activity under 'socialism' very diverse in the 1830s
New Forces: Nationalism
- Common characteristics bind people together, therefore these should be the basis for nation-states
- Similarity rather than difference?
- Exclusionary?
- Still embryonic
New Forces Combined 1
- Elites fear the new social forces - because they perceive them as threatening their position
- Historians agree that 1848 revolutions were characterised by a lack of philosophical coherence importance of local conditions. Interactions between global forces and local conditions
New Forces Combined 2
How did we get to revolution?
- Marxists: Revolutions were spontaneous and were precipitated by financial and food shortages - but gap between ideology and reality of the revolution which apparently was corrosive
- Elite inaction of paralysis - allowed opportunistic workers to act
Crisis of the 1840s
- Economic deterioration as contribution to revolutions hotly contested by historians
- Does it make any sense to separate politics and the economy
- Agricultural crisis-crop failure - increase in grain and bread prices, BUT food riots is not only explanation
- Financial and industrial crisis (esp. France) - depressed investment lack of financial confidence - unemployment
Agricultural crisis
- 70% of working class income spent on food, price of grain rose between 100%-150% - price rises especially in France
Financial and industrial collapse
- Food crisis and financial - industrial collapse interacted cumulative effect
- France: 1841 purchase of land for railway building
- Rise in bankruptcies of the petite bourgeoisie
- Production - Profit
- Middle class withdrew support for the regime when not working fo them - The Definitive Factor in the Revolutions
- Collision of political - economic and social instabilities
Revolution gathering pace
- National guard defected
- Elite interaction working class opportunism
- Revolution only made possible when middle class "switch" sides?
- The city as the focus of the revolution - circulation of pamphlets and leaflets. Ruling elites couldn't control the centres
1848: Commonalities or divergences
- Revolutions so widespread, historians have invariably looked for common threads
- Domino effect? France than "the rest"?
France 1
- Regime losing credibility
- Guizot's government faced opposition, opponents wanted reform, not revolution (liberal)
- Administration tainted by scandal and corruption, therefore legitimacy weakening - Guizot not strong enough
- More banquets (political meetings taking place)
- 1846, some parliamentary reforms, but too slow
- Banquets banned = demonstrations - Barricades
France 2: What happened?
- Regime faltered because:
1. Defection of National guard
2. Collective malaise
- Creation of power vacuum
- 24th February - Chamber invaded by armed insurgents elite politicians also lose confidence
France 3
- February revolution - relatively bloodless
- Provisional government set up - dominated by moderates who a) weren't far-reaching enough in their agenda b) populated by people with different priorities so a lack of coherence
- Main priorities of government:
1. Finance - needed people to spend money
2. Political consolidation
3. Social issues - reduce unemployment issues
- Fear that people would push for more reforms
France 4
- French society becoming more polarised
- Working class = "too radical", Middle class switch allegiance - support repression
- Middle class - Balance power
- June days - Aftermath = growing strength of the right
- Bonaparte wheeled in as "bankable" name to take charge, brutal repression, restoration of status quo
Habsburg Lands 1
- Following France?
- Or something quite different altogether?
- 13th March 1848 Metternich resigns as Chancellor defiguring moment: been in power too long & desire for liberal reform
Habsburg Lands 2
- Did "1848" happen to Habsburg lands because a lack of cohesion between the ruling elite, rather than REAL revolutionary fever
- Dominant modes of interpretation
1. Middle-class revolution framed by liberal reform (party of progress)
2. National revolution
- Had to balance what different groups of people wanted
- People wanted a national post-revolutionary world
Habsburg Lands 3
- March Laws
- Magyar nationalism, as exclusionary nationalism?
- Czech nationalism, liberal programme
- October days: repression - Viennese bourgeoisie on side of elites
- Counter-revolution because of nationalism? Because of lack of coherence
- Liberalism and nationalism weakened in 1848
German lands
- Not a geographical identity in strict sense, but in 1848 "unites" in context of spread of liberal nationalism
German lands 2
- Middle-class liberal in nature, but some divergence with working class aspirations
- Capitalist development uneven
- Prussia: Monarchy acquiesce to revolution - through fear and indecision
- New liberals want democratic reform but within structure of existing order
- Revolutions fuelled because of a lack of common ground between revolutionaries
Italian Peninsula
- Is Italy different? Do the revolutions pre-date France
- Revolution in Peninsula had made considerable headway
Italian Peninsula 2
1. Revolution again Austrian rule in Lombardy and Venetia - escalated into war
2. General demand for more liberal and democratic governance
3. Urban craftsmen and artisans wanted social revolution
Italian Peninsula 3
- Living standards big issues: Naples life expectancy 24 in 1840
- Majority employed in agriculture - Agriculture practices inefficient
- Urban workers = Vanguard - peasants also supporters
- Italian workers and peasants motivated by complex interplay between economic grievances
- Revolutionary spirit short lived, some satisfied with liberal concessions, counter-revolution swift
Related discussions on The Student Room
- Is rereading my Literature texts now (AQA GCSE) going to help me at all? »
- History a level coursework »
- aqa english lit - paper 1/2 confusion »
- Macbeth essay »
- DMU - A Rich and Vibrant History of Improving Lives through Education »
- A-level History NEA Coursework »
- Aqa literature paper 1 »
- Y216 The USA in the 19th Century: Westward expansion and Civil War 1803–c.1890 »
- Help with A Level English Lit Coursework Please!!! »
- Evaluate the interpretations »
Comments
No comments have yet been made