1. an event that has religious significance - allows events that are outside the laws of nature and allows subjectivity as to what has religious significance
2. event caused by God - no subjectivity and would be considered
3. event that violates the laws of nature - most common view - objective
Problem with third definition is that if you define a law of nature as general and contingent then a miracle would cause the law not to be general - this means miracles do not break laws of nature and are not therefore miracles
Could redefine as miracle is an event outside the law of nature - e.g laws of nature apply to natural events - miracle is not natural as caused by God - law is physically not logically impossible
Swinburne argues miracle is non-repeatable - problem e.g. feeding of thousands
Comments
No comments have yet been made