Involuntary Manslaughter
- Created by: Serena King
- Created on: 29-10-12 14:22
What is the definiton of Unlawful Act Manslaughter
Killing by doing an act which is both 'unlawful' and 'dangerous'
What is the actus reus for UAM? (1)
1) An unlawful act
i) an omission is not sufficient - Lowe
ii) must be a crime not a mere tort - Franklin
iii) the act can be an non fatal offence, criminal damage, arson, burglary, robbery or the misuse of drugs act - Lamb, R v D, Goodfellow, Watson, Dawson, Kennedy
What is the actus reus for UAM? (2)
2) The act must be dangerous (Reasonable man/Objective Test)
i) Sober and reasonable person test - Church
ii) Reasonable person has the same knowledge as D - Dawson
iii) Obvious to reasonable observer - Watson/Carey
iv) Dangerousness decided by reasonable person - Ball
What is the actus reus for UAM? (3)
3) The act must have caused the death
i) Factual causation 'but for' test - White/Pagett
ii) Legal causation: operating and substantial cause Smith/Jordan, novus actus interveniens Roberts, thin skull rule Blaue
iii) Unlawful act must cause the death i.e there must be a causal link Watson/Kennedy/Carey/Johnstone
What is the mens rea for UAM?
It is simply that of the crime constituting the unlawful act which may be intention or recklessness depending on the definition of the particular offence (Lamb)
N.B There is no mens rea if it is a strict liability offence (Andrews)
What is the definition of Gross Negligence Manslau
Adomako
The requirements for GNM are:
1) The existence of a duty of care
2) The breach of that duty causing death
3) Gross negligence which the jury considers justifies a criminal conviction
What is the actus reus for GNM? (1)
1) GNM can be committed by an act or an omission
i) An act Prentice
ii) An omission Khan & Khan
iii) An act or an omission Adomako
What is the actus reus for GNM? (2)
2) D must owe a duty of care to V
i) A criminal duty (relates to omissions only and the 5 duties to act) Evans
ii) A civil duty of care - tort (relates to act and omissions) Adomako/Donoghue v Stevenson/Caparo/Singh
(Civil or Criminal? Adomako/Wacker/Willoughby)
What is the actus reus for GNM? (3)
3) Breach of Duty of Care
i) Was the duty breached by an act or omission? Nettleship v Weston/Bolam
ii) The breach must have created an obvious risk of death Misra
What is the actus reus for GNM? (4)
4) It must have caused the victims death
i) Factual causation 'but for' test - White/Pagett
ii) Legal causation: operating and substantial cause Smith/Jordan, novus actus interveniens Roberts, thin skull rule Blaue
What is the mens rea for GNM?
The mens rea is GROSS NEGLIGENCE (Adomako), an objective test where the standard is;
"what would the sober and reasonable person have done?"
The negligence must be 'so bad in all the circumstances' to amount to negligence. D must have had 'criminal disregard for others safety' or 'the grossest ignorance or the most criminal inattention'.
The mens rea can cover both objective and subjective criteria Lidar
UAM Ratios - Church
'such as all sober and reasonable people would inevitably recognise must subject the other person to, at least, the risk of some harm resulting there from, albeit not serious harm'
GNM Ratios - Adomako (1) and (2)
(1)
The requirements for GNM are:
1) The existence of a duty of care
2) The breach of that duty causing death
3) Gross negligence which the jury considers justifies a criminal conviction
(2)
Gross negligence is that which the jury considers justifies a criminal conviction. Having regard to the risk of death involved was the conduct of D so bad as to amount to a criminal act or omission
GNM Ratios - Bateman
'In order to establish criminal liability, the facts must be such that in the opinion of the jury, the negligence went beyond a mere matter of compensation between the subjects and showed such disregard for the life and safety of others as to amount to a crime against the State and conduct deserving punishment'
Related discussions on The Student Room
- Regarding a level law »
- Does anyone have Law a level essay writing techniques?? »
- Shouldn't Euthanasia be made freely available to all sick old people now? because »
- AQA A Level Law Paper 1 26th May 2023 »
- involuntary manslaughter a level law »
- Immar's advice for anyone wanting to study Law »
- law irac method help »
- Law conversion / GDL »
- OCR law 2023 »
- Cambridge Interview »
Comments
No comments have yet been made