Feminism and religion
0.0 / 5
- Created by: Caitlyn jade
- Created on: 25-02-23 17:08
Rosemary Radford Reuther
- She says we are to view God as being outside of the parameters of gender
- there is a view that men are more authentically human than women, this view can be found in the bible and in philosophy
- androcentrism is the term for this: focused or centred on men in culture and history
- the fall in genesis 3:16 shows women in a negative light as the fall is the fault of eve and not Adam
- Aristotle also calls women 'misbegotten males' that should be ruled by men who posses reason
- augustine and Aristotle believed that the male hierarchy is everything to do with god's plan
1 of 6
RRR’s argument
What is male and what is female?
- They both have different reproductive roles
- our nature is androgynous meaning masculinity and feminity come from culture
Mary and Eve
- Mary is presented as a role model for women because she is obedient and passive whereas eve sin because she is rebellious and disobedient
- having mary as a role model is problematic because this encourages women to be easily manipulated by men
marginalised forms of Christianity
- some marginalised forms of Christianity are till relevant to fem theology today, such as montaism which believes the Holy Spirit is given to both men an women
- quakers also wrote ofGod with female qualities and some include women as leaders
- the shakers promoted the view that both male and female was created in gods image
- however, not all indications have seen sexism in Christianity
2 of 6
RRR’s argument 2
The prophetic tradition
- feminist theology is part of the prophetic tradition in the bible as God defended the oppressed such as women and the religious ideology maintains justice
- jesus is part of this tradition as he gave women places of power, such as Mary M
- because of this Reuther says we must reclaim the view of jesus in 'maleness'
problems and solutions
- romanticism acts as a social salvation to embrace female qualities but it leaves women trapped in romantic egoism
- liberalism gives women the chance to enter education that is dominated by men but women would hire lower class women and exploit them
- Marxism allows women to enter work alongside men but women are then expected to work at home aswell
3 of 6
Mary Daly
- She says the goal for human life is to all be free to engage in A journey of growth with the use of verbs
- In reality women have been treated as objects and viewed as nouns
God is not a noun
- She says the static view of god has helped women turn into objects in theology
- traditional theology views god as timeless, static, creating an ruling
- the three versions of a noun-god are: an explanation, otherworldly, judge of sin
- she says this noun-god must be dethroned and we should follow jesus as he is the role model for all Christianity
god is a verb
- we should see god as a verb because he is the force that helps us to fulfil
- female language t describe god is insufficient becuse it perpetuates the idea of god as a noun (critiquing Sallie Mcfague)
4 of 6
Mary Daly 2
The unholy trinity
- she says treating women as objects is at the heart of all violence
- she turns the holy trinity into an unholy trinity with ****, genocide and war as she says this turns oppression into a means to increase our pleasure or decrease our pain
- she says **** reinforces the need for male protection, genocide creates objectification and war creates masculine dominance
the need for sisterhood
- The church is too bound to patriarchy to ever become a place where women can find comfort
- women should become 'anti-church' and leave the church to create ew communities
- sisterhood allows us to find relationships with other women to oppose the lovelessness of sexually hierarchical society
- in conclusion, women should leave the church in pursuit of liberation
5 of 6
Ordination
- ordination is done a a gathering in a church where people lay hands on the one to be ordained and bring the Holy Spirit unto them, in 1994, women were ordained for the first time
- in the early church we can see women in leadership positions such as Mary M to be the first to see Jesus and were considered apostles
- there are many reasons why women hold not be part of the ministry such as: god came down and incarnated as male, scripture forbids it and Christ appointed men as apostles
- these are some good arguments why women should be ordained; jesus didnt restive his message to men, women were ordained in the early church, many passages talk of inclusive ministry
- most churches do not ordain women and pope Francis onfirmed that he wouldnt break the tradition
- there are problems for women to face when they are ordained such as, maternity pay, women find it hard to move up the system and there is a growing proportion of unpaid female clergy
6 of 6
Related discussions on The Student Room
- A Level Philosophy / Religious studies »
- islam and christian »
- Why is religion against sex? »
- OCR Sociology Paper 3 Predictions »
- Difference between Religious Studies A and Religious Studies B »
- Religious studies aqa gcse »
- Philosophy A-Level advice »
- gcse aqa religious studies help please »
- Don't know how to revise GCSE (short course) Religious studies »
- Black girl and Pakistani guy »
Similar Religious Studies resources:
3.5 / 5 based on 2 ratings
3.0 / 5 based on 2 ratings
0.0 / 5
0.0 / 5
0.0 / 5
0.0 / 5
0.0 / 5
5.0 / 5 based on 7 ratings
Comments
No comments have yet been made