Aetiologies of unipolar depression
- Created by: gracepxx
- Created on: 21-05-16 13:09
P1 - Intro
Depression is most common mental disorder
Strong evidence that its caused by both psychological and physiological factors
Possible that they work together, and that some factors may create depression in the first place, whereas others maintain it
P2 - Physiological - Twins
Research using twins show that there could be a genetic basis for this condition - twin studies use MZ twins sharing 100% of genes and DZ twins sharing 50%
Greater similarities between MZ wins than DZ - role of genes has been substantial
McGuffin et al (1996) studied 177 probands with depression and their same sex twin - found concordance rate for MZ twins was 46% but just 20% for DZ - suggests depression has genetic component but must also be influenced by other things
When compared to other disorders, concordance rates for depression are relatively low - explained by comorbidity - when two or more mental illnesses occur together and prehaps have a common cause
People may inherit a vulnerability to many disorders rather than just depression and so we'd expect to see a higher concordance when looking at range of disorders in related people
Kendler et al (1992) supported this, finding a higher incidence of mental disorders in twins when looking at depression and generalised this to anxiety as a whole
P3 - Physiological - Genes as diatheses
Genetic factors thought to act as diatheses in a diathesis-stress relationship
Genetic predisposition for depression needs to interact with environmental stressors to produce a depressive reaction
Kendler et al (1995) - women who were the co-twin of depressed sibling were more likely to become depressed than those without the vulnerability
Also found that the highest level of depression was found in group exposed to significant negative life events as well as being most genetically at risk - suggest both play a role
P4 - Physiological - Genes
If research correct and depression has genetic basis then researchers should be able to locate responsible genes
One gene thoought to contribute is the one which is responsible for producing serotonin in brain
This gene comes in three forms, varying in the length of its two stands - believed the form with two short strands leads to insufficient serotonin levels causing depression
Kendler's work supported by Willhelm at al (2006) - negative life events were linked to depression but most importantly, those individuals who had short-short version of the serotonin gene were most vulnerable
However, vulnerability created by gene was only made apparent when also experienced negative life events suggesting depression is caused by combination of both
P5 - Physiological - Noradrenaline
Second physiological explanation is that depression is caused by neurotransmitter dysfunction
1960s - proposed that depression comes from deficient of neurotransmitter noradrenaline
Bunney and Davis (1965) - indirect markers of noradrenaline such as the by-products found in urine were often low in depressed inviduals - suggesting there wasn't as much noradrenaline
Role of noradrenaline supported by the fact drugs which cause noradrenaline depletion induce depressive states
Kraft et al (2005) treated patients with a noradrenaline reuptake inhibitor and they showed a significantly more positive response than those treated with placebo
P6 - Physiological - Serotonin
Supporting link between low synaptic setononin levels and depression
Cerebrospinal fluid in depression contraining reduced amount of serotonin by-products suggesting reduced levels in the brain itself
Introducing of prozac and other antidepressant drugs that block serotonin reuptake confirmed the association between serotonin and depression
Delgado et al (1990) gave depressied patients who were recieving antidepressant medication a special diet which reduced their levels of the precursors of serotonin - majority of patients experienced a return of depressive symptoms which disappeared again when diet returned to near normal
Some studies use patients whose depression is in remission - Ruhe et al (2007) gave them an amino acid mixture to eat that temporarily reduces levels of serotonin in the brain and they tended to experience brief relapse of symptoms - suggests low serotonin causes depression
P7 - Psychological - Psychodynamic
Freud (1917) propsed that some cases of depression could be explained by genetic factors, but many cases were linked to childhood eperiences of loss or rejection which had been repressed
Individuals harbour negatvie feelings towards those they love - later in life, if someone is lost the repressed feelings resurgace but are turned inwards
Frued emphasised role of anger in mourning and depression and to him, depression was "anger turned against onself"
Studies found many people who suffer with illness describe their parents as "affectionless" supporting Frued's theory of "loss" through withdrawral of affection causing depression
Bifulco et al (1992) found evidence that children whose mothers die in early childhood were more likely to become depressed in later life - also found association could be explained by lack of care from parents and parent substitutes following loww, rather than loss itself
Paykel and Cooper also suggested early loss accounts for only small amount of depression with just 10% of those who experience loss becoming depressed, suggesting other causes for depression
P8 - Psychological - Cognitive - Beck
Beck (1967) believed that depressed individuals think as they do because they are biased towards negative interpretations of the world and have a negative schema
Could be caused by many favtors and activated whenever individual encounters a new situation that resembles original conditions in which the schema were learned
Negative schema maintain what Beck calls the negative triad - pessimistic view of self, world and future which causes depression
Beck's research supported by Hammen and Krantz (1976) who found depressed women make more errors in logic when asked to interpret written material than non-depressed - show fault in thinking
However, as with many epxplanations, the fact that there is alink between negative thoughts and depression doesnt mean former causes latter
P9 - Psychological - Cognitive - Learned Helplessn
Seligman (1975) proposed depression may be learned when person tries but fails to control an unpleasant circumstance so develops sense of being unable to control their life - Learned helplessness impairs their performance in situations that could be controlled
Person prone to depression is thought to show a depressive attributional style - accepting they cant change how their life goes and accepting their depressive state
Although Seligman's initial research was based on study of animals, learned helplessness has been supported by human studies
Miller and Seligman (1974) found that depressed students exposed to an uncontrollable event performed worst of all on similar cognitive tasks - findings sugges tthat having some depree of control is likely to improve performance expecially for those depressed
Related discussions on The Student Room
- Graduate medicine query »
- Paper 3B: Global politics »
- Abnormal liver function test results, is there any hope things will get better? »
- Exam deferral circumstances - is it likely I succeed? »
- Edexcel A-level Psychology Paper 2 (9PS0 02) - 25th May 2023 [Exam Chat] »
- really struggling mentally »
- Wondering if my penis is Normal size »
- Module selection (psychology ) »
- Effects of Citalopram (20mg) on me, and general situation? »
- antidepressents »
Comments
No comments have yet been made