Tony Sewell - Underachievement of Black Boys

?
  • Created by: mbeales
  • Created on: 15-01-16 09:44

Key Ideas

Evaluation

  • Black boys saw no point in qualifications because they feel that racism in wider society would stop them getting a good job regardless.
  • Lack of legitimate opportunities to get a good education.
  • Black boys are statistically more likely to be in poverty and live in cultural deprived areas with a high proportion of single mother households.
  • Gang culture has led to anti-school pressure from peers.
  • Teachers have low expectations of education success due to their awareness that external factors will affect their learning. Results in lack of self-belief – an 'Oxford’s not for me' attitude.
  • Argued against Gilborn’s who believed  that under achievement was due to teacher racism, believed it to be other factors.
  • Sewell doesn’t accept that a disadvantaged background is an excuse for failure.
  • Ignores white working class underachievement and girls achievement.
  • Lack of representativeness as a tiny sample used compared to the bigger picture.
  • Lack of control of variables means that it cannot be proved that it was solely the program that made the difference; whether the new found contact or the program acting as an incentive to try harder are examples.

Key Terms

Methods

  • Studied African-Caribbean boys in a comprehensive all were working class.
  • The generating genius experiment 25 black boys from failing schools interested in science and engineering. 2006 (age 12-13) boys spent at least 3 weeks in the summer holidays working alongside scientists at Britain’s top universities  Sewell claims that these boys got amazing GCSE results. First wave have had their university acceptances, at least 3 have made it into Oxford and Cambridge

Comments

No comments have yet been made