Critical responses

?

Troilus and Cressida- not saying no- Grace Tiffany 

Brandy Schillace 

  • Two camps in the play only seem radically opposed
  • Both camps share a common language and perspective- demonstrate women as passive
  • Cressida loses her own identity and value by giving up her own voice
  • Cressida suppresses her own independent voice
  • Apart from being a piece in a war between men, Cressida doesn't seem to have much value in the patriarchal society in which she lives in
  • 'things won are undone'- fears she will be rejected. Believes in the lack of worth society has placed on her
  • Value in the play seems redundant because of how willing people in the play are to fight each other- disregard to human life- probably because there is a war on
  • Value is important in regards to men- what women want is not important
  • Self divide- Cressida seems virtuous but she betrays her love and gets with someone else- Is she acting out and not valuing herself because society doesn't value her.
  • Moby ****- 'concerning masculinity and its discontents'
  • gender representations are an attempt to define the soul/self
  • Soul of a man on an enormous scale
  • Ahab pulls the text forward and drags the rest along
  • Could be described as a 'tale of the heart'
  • Could be described as a 'religious quest'
  • David Lerenz-  a man's book about avenging his shattered manhood

Sashi Nair

Morgan Winifred 

  • Talks about the absence of Criseyde in her own characterisation
  • She is excluded from the final stages of the narrative
  • Troilus is different from Cressida because he is forced to fall in love whereas Criseyde decides to persue the romance
  • 'astoned'- at the sight of her
  • Talks about female subjectivity
  • Criseyde can be seen as a 'personification' for the vulnerable widow
  • The narratives are appealing to the humanity that they share with the readers
  • Focus on the moral bankruptcy of slavery
  • Talks about the dedication Douglas had in regards to helping others flee slavery
  • Knowledge represents power
  • Anti- Slave movement in 1838 had wood engravings of men beating slaves

Comments

No comments have yet been made