Religion, Renewal and Choice

Little mindmap based on the Rob Webb chapter of the same name

View mindmap
  • Religion, renewal and choice
    • Believing without belonging
      • Grace Davie (2007)- argues against secularisation. Instead thinks that people believe but don't practice
        • Vicarious Religion- where a small number of prof clergy practise religion on behalf of small number of people
        • Evidence- Bibby (1993)-  25% canadians attended church regularly, 80% said they were religious
          • Vicarious Religion- where a small number of prof clergy practise religion on behalf of small number of people
      • Criticism- Voas and Crockett (2005)- evidence from surveys show attendance AND belief= declining
    • Spiritual Shopping
      • Hervieu- Leger (2000;2006)
        • Dramatic decline in institutional religion in Eurtope, 'cultural amnesia'- we don't inherit fixed religious identity so we choose
          • Two new religious movements- Pilgrims (follow path for self discovery) and Converts (join groups with strong sense of belonging)
    • Lyon- 'Jesus in Disneyland'
      • Traditional religion = given way to a variety of new religious forms
        • Globalisation= movement of ideas, ideas= disembedded. Harvest Day Crusade at Disneyland- boundaries blurred. Rel= de-institutionalised
        • Postmodern society= growth of consumerism. Means we pick and mix elements of religion to find identity. Means religion isn't abandoned but loss of faith in 'meta- narratives'
        • Lyon sees this as 're-enchantment', proof against secularisation, form has just changed
        • BUT PMists see growth of electronic rel media as evidence against secularisation
    • Religious Market Theory
      • Stark and Bainbridge (1985)- secularisation theory is eurocentric and distorted
      • RMT is based on a) people are naturally religious so demand remains constant and b) it's human nature to seek reward and weigh up costs and benefits
      • Religion thrives in the US because there's never been a religious monopoly unlike europe where big rel orgs led to decline in others- lack of supply/ Biggest factor in secularisation
      • Criticisms- Bruce- says S&B misinterpreted theory. Norris& Inglehart- study found countries with dominant church practise more, contradicts them
    • Existential Security Threat
      • Norris and Inglehart- reasons for variations in religiosity between countries= differing degrees of 'existential secularity'- the feeling that survival is secure enough to be taken for granted
        • Poor countries- high level of insecurity- high level of religion
        • Rich countries- secure- less need for religion
      • Europe vs America- Western Europe becoming secular because it's secure, US isn't because it's 'unequal'
      • EVIDENCE- Gill & Lundegaarde- the more a country spends on social welfare, the lower the level of rel participation
      • BUT Vasquez (2007) says they don't examine individual definitions of 'existential security' and they only see religion as negative response to deprivation


No comments have yet been made

Similar Sociology resources:

See all Sociology resources »See all Religion and beliefs resources »