Diminished responsibility is where the person is suffering an abnormality of the mind arising from a specific cause, substnacially impairign his mental reponsibility.
Diminished responsibility often recognises new conditions. In bryne an abnormality of mind was defined as 'a state so different from an ordinary man, that a reasonable man woudl see it as abnormal'.
In Hobson, D was suffering from batered wife syndrome, her husband often abused her, she killed him and raised diminished responsibility. This was allowed for the first time.
Hobson was followed in the case of thornton and Auhuwalia.
In seers it was clear that when deciding an abnormality of mind they must not refer to insanity.
An abnormality must have a specific cause, mainly internal. In di cuca it was decided that intoxication will never succeed. Later changed in Fenton, it is allowed if there is a pre-existing disorder.
Comments
Report