Limitations
Deviation from social norms
susceptible to abuse:
- varies as time changes
- Szasz (1974) claimed that the concept of mental ilness was simply a way to exclude nonconformist from society
Deviation is related to context and dgree:
- swimming costume on a beach/swimming costume in the street
- seen as abnormal or indication of mental disorder
- being rude is deiviant behaviour, not mental disturbance, unless excessive (pathological)
- social deviance on its own cannot offer a definition of abnormality
- social deviance is inevitably related to both context and degree
Cultural relativism
- cultural factors influence social norms (cultural relativism)
- social norms are defined by the culture
- disorders are defined or diagnosed in different ways in different places by different groups
- diagnoses may be different for the same person in two different cultures
- cultural relativism has become an acknowleged fact
- DSM includes a glossary that describes patterns of behaviour and syndromes that only occurs in certain areas (culture bound syndromes)
- no universal standards or rules for labelling abnormal behaviour
Comments
No comments have yet been made