Main Contenders in the power struggle after Lenin's death
- Created by: _awesome_E
- Created on: 20-12-14 11:46
Trotsky -Revolutionary Record
His reputation was established in the 1905 revolution
Leading figure in the short St Petersburg Soviet of November 1905, organising a general strike of the workers
Masterminded the communist service of power and reconstruction of the Red Army during the civil war of 1918-1921
Trotsky - Relationship with Lenin
Early relationship with Lenin was tubulent
1903 side with Mensheviks rejecting Lenin's views
When he returned to Russia in 1913 he however joined the communist party and worked closley with Lenin
Throughout the civil war, he and Lenin worked together on restoring discipline to the Red Army
Trotsky - Lenin's Testament
Trotsky was Lenin's Principal Lieutenant and dispite the occacional disagreement Lenin was happy to proclaim his as 'no better communist'
In his testament he wrote 'the most able in the present centre committee' however he also wrote that 'too far reaching self-confident'
Trotsky - Party Appeal
Revolutionary heroism in 1905, 1917 and during the civil war
He had good speaking skills and won the support of young communists and the Red Army
Disliked by many as he was not a typical communist (western), so had many enemies
Trotsky -Party Powerbase
Had a seat in the politburo at the time of Lenin's death
Trotsky -Government Powerbase
Part of the minesterial committee within the Sovnarkom
His most important role was the Head of the Red Army
Stalin -Revolutionary Record
During and after the October Revolution he was a committee member
Saw himself as a milltary tactician, refusing to accept Trotsky's authority during civil war
1921, his presence on many senior committee secured him a high level of government
Stalin - Relationship with Lenin
During 1905 Lenin came to rely on Stalin's administrative ability and loyalty
Proir to Lenin's illness Stalin was careful to back him on contraversial issues
However as Lenin began to fall ill Stalin began to oppse him
Stalin - Lenin's Testament
In his testament Lenin was highly critical of Stalin especially after following a disagreement between Stalin and his wife
He demanded that other party leaders tryed to come up with a way to remove him and find someone more tolerant, loyal, polite, and more considerate to others
However he did also state that along with Trotsky he was one of the most able of those in the centre commitee
Stalin - Party Appeal
Had the power to advance people in their careers in the communist party
He was also relatively calm compared to Trotsky and Bukharin who became quite extreme
Unlike the other potential leaders he was willing to appeal to the nation to gain his lead
Stalin - Party Powerbase
Was the obvious choice to get the chair in the centre committee but he didn't get it so was given General Secretary which is the Head of the Secretariat, created by Lenin
He was also Head of the Centre Control Commission and he had a Politburo seat
Stalin - Government Powerbase
Member of the minesterial committee in the Sovnarkom
He was also the Commissar of Nationalities within the Sovnarkom
The expansion of the Sovnarkom in 1919 lead to him being given the position of Commissar of the workers' and peasants' inspectorate (Rabkrin)
Power of Patronage ensured that workers who wanted to keep their jobs would be loyal to him
Bukharin - Revolutionary Record
Leading figure during 1917 in the Moscow Communist party
Following the October Revolt his radicalism inspired others to seize power in Moscow
during the civil war his revolutionism encourged German Communists to rise up and seize power in thier own country
Bukharin - Relationship with Lenin
He admired Lenin, Lenin referred to him as the 'Golden Boy' of the Communist Party however he and Lenin often didn't agree on things
Following the revolution, he headed up the first oppostion group, criticising Lenin's peace policies with Germany
At the end of the civil war, he turned back on his early radicalism and went back to embrace Lenin's new economic policies
Bukharin - Lenin's Testament
In the testament Lenin wrote that he was one of his favourite out of the whole party and that he had 'the most able force amougst youngsters'
However Lenin also had his reservations about his skills as a theorist, 'his theoretical view can only with the greatest of doubt be regarded as fully marxist'
Bukharin - Party Appeal
He was liked by many in the party that in 1921 a foreign vistor to Moscow said that he was 'named in Russia as the eventual successor to Lenin'
He had a reputation for honesty, fairness and incorruptibly
Bukharin - Party Powerbase
He was in charge of education and newspapers
He had a seat on the Politburo and was a candidate member
Bukharin - Government Powerbase
No position in the Sovnarkom
Kamenev - Revolutionary Record
Known for his caution rather than his revolutionary passion
Disagreed with Lenin on several strategies e.g. October Revolution and the new government
Also played no part in the civil war
Kamenev - Relationship with Lenin
After Zinoviev, he was Lenin's closest friends and collaborator prior to 1917
However in 1917 he began to oppose Lenin's vision along with others
Following the revolution however he went back to Lenin and remained close to him into his final years
Kamenev - Lenin's Testament
Lenin bracketed him and Zinoviev reminding his readers of their unloyalty during the crucial months in 1917
Kamenev - Party Appeal
He had little ambition
Saw no need to consolidate his support base
He was intellectual but an unispiring public speaker
Reputation of giving up easily and compromising
Kamenev - Party Powerbase
After 1919 was given a seat in the Politburo, yet after Lenin's death he was given chairman of the centre committee
Also head of the Moscow branch, however being a poor administrator he therefore failed to earn the respect of the party
Kamenev - Government Powerbase
Originally served as deputy chair of the Sovnarkom
When Lenin became ill and Trotsky refused he became the acting chair of the Sovnarkom therefore also the acting head of the Soviet Government
Zinoviev - Revolutionary Record
Short of revolutionary heroism
October 1917, opposed the planned takeover of power - October Deserter
During civil war remained in Petrograd's most luxurious hotel, away from the fighting
Zinoviev - Relationship with Lenin
During his exile worked with Lenin on books and pamphlets until his return in 1917
However on his return he disagreed with Lenin on crucial issues
After dropping again he returned to the position as his henchman
Zinoviev - Lenin's Testament
However Lenin still wrote in his testament, 'I will only remind you that the October episode of Zinoviev and Kamenev was not of course, accidental'
Zinoviev - Party Appeal
He was the least appealing for the power
Good speaker but vain, with abition and ovious political failings
Zinoviev - Party Powerbase
From 1919 had the position of the Head of the Comintern
He had a seat on the Politburo
Also he was the head of the Petrograd branch of the local party groups
Zinoviev - Government Powerbase
No position in the Sovnarkom
Related discussions on The Student Room
- Why are young men so different than before? »
- What Should I pick for my Year 13 History Option »
- Who's your favourite historical figure? »
- A Level - History coursework - which question is the best//most interesting »
- A-level History Study Group 2023-2024 »
- Just Chatting »
- year 13 gyg journal : trying not to become an academic victim 🤡📖 »
- Clash of ideologies A2 CCEA 2024 exam »
- Edexcel A Level History Paper 1 (9HI0 1A-1H) - 24th May 2023 [Exam Chat] »
- Is my uni list too ambitious? »
Comments
No comments have yet been made