"Someone help me get the strap over, I - can't - do - it"
"Mother O'God let me live" - fear of death, not suited for war. Religious reference = desperation
"Shaking like a leaf" - imagery shows fear, lack of patriotism - going against everything Rudyard said about enlistment
"Do I have to take the basket across if the pigeon's dead, sir?" - soldiers are only following orders, doesn't know anything about war and surviving - no sense of logic, lack of common sense. Also shows fear - he can't focus or concentrate properly
"Bowe scrabbles in the mud" - animalistic, driven by instincts and the need to survive - id. No thought or logic, no noble sacrifice. Anticipate him as a weak character
1 of 4
How is John presented in the trenches?
John:
He is assertive, he appears commanding over the other soldiers, not a child amnymore
"McHugh...I'm trying...I'm trying" - he's trying to remain calm, to be mature, an adult
Military jargin shows lack of true understanding - only repeating orders
"Listen everyone"
"You will...you'll find a way" - sets and controls agenda: commanding verbs
"Shut up! Shut up! Of course, dump the bloody thing." - no longer calm and controlled - shows fear and inexperience, he is not suited for war
2 of 4
How is John presented in the soliloquy?
Soliloquy:
"Oh Daddo" - he has regresesed, a child again. Commanding officer just a facade, not who he is. He is a child again - he is terrified of death but still thinking of his father - not let him down etc. - be a man.
"Please God I mustn't let them down." - Talking about his troops and his father's unrealistic expectations of him - he's a child really
Use of punctuation - "Keep the pistol out of the mud - left hand on the parapet - pull -" - it's a system, a ritual he has to go through it to focus and stay sane. Programmed, a machine. Stream of consciousness
"Please God let me live." - religious speech, relying on something superior to him to try and survuve - similar language to Bowe - PTSD
3 of 4
How is camaraderie presented?
Camaraderie:
Presence of camaraderie is a massive lie built up by the home front. In reality it doesn't exist - all men are scared of dying but it doesn't bring them close
"Don't point your scabby **** at me!" - lack of camaraderie - it's every man for himself, no strong connection between soldiers
"**** - **** - **** off Bowe!" - no camaraderie at all, hostility towards other soldiers
Reality of war, not what propaganda puts forward
"You can take mine Bowe." - sudden support from McHugh in front of John to impress him
Comments
No comments have yet been made