All of these theories have arguments against them and debates about them too:
Deterrence doesn't work. In the UK, prisons are crammed full to bursting point and nearly half of all prisoners commit crime again after they are released. If deterrence did work, this would suggest that those countries that have very severe punishments would have low levels of crime, which is not the case.
In many cases retribution doesn't work either. Victims of crime often feel that the criminal has not been punished enough, so they do not feel a sense of justice having been done.
Some people would argue that, in very serious crimes such as murder, retribution can never be reached anyway. The family of the victim will still be grieving their loss, no matter how harshly the murderer is punished for it.
Some people argue that reform goes against the idea of punishing people, which is what they punishment should be about. They would argue that teaching and educating criminals is not punishing them.
Comments
Report