Crime and Punishment

Why do laws need to be just?

  • If a law is unjust, people will feel that it is right to break the law.
  • If some laws are unjust, people will think that all laws are unjust. They will think that the government is not doing their job.
  • People will not obey the law and will campaign against it causing trouble in society
  • People will think the legal system is not working and they may start a civil war.
1 of 23

Why do some Christians support Capital Punishment?

  • The Bible gives the death penalty as punishment for some offences.
  • Roman Catholic Church and the Church of England haven't cancelled their statements that Capital Punishment can be used by the state.
  • Christian Church used Capital Punishment for heresy.
  • St Thomas Aquinas said that the protection of society is more important than the reform of the criminal.
2 of 23

Why do some Christians oppose Capital Punishment?

  • Jesus came to reform sinners, but you can't reform a dead person.
  • Jesus said that an eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth is wrong for Christians.
  • Christianity teaches that all life is sacred (abortion and euthanasia are wrong, so is Captial Punishment).
  • Most Christian Churches have made statements condemning Capital Punishment.
3 of 23

Why do most Muslims support Capital Punishment?

  • Punishment by God in the Qur'an.
  • Muhammed made statements agreeing with Capital Punishment for apostasy, adultery and murder.
  • Muhammed sentenced people to death for murder.
  • Shari'ah says that Capital Punishment is the punishment for apostasy, adultery and murder.
4 of 23

What are Non-Religious arguments in favour of Capi

Capital Punishment?

  • If people know they will die if they murder someone, it will put them off murdering.
  • Murderers and terrorists threaten society. The best way to protect society is by taking away their lives.
  • Human life is important. The value of life can only be shown by giving murderers the worst punishment (death).
  • Retribution is a part of punishment. Only retribution for murder is the death penalty (an eye for an eye).
5 of 23

What are the strengths and weaknesses of the 4

Theories of Punishment?

  • Retribution - makes criminals pay and suffer. It also actually punishes the criminal.
  • Reform - the only way to stop crime and most criminals had a bad upbringing and they don't know how to live without crime. It gives criminals an education and qualifications.
  • Protection - capital punishment works because you can't kill if you're dead. Long prison sentences keep criminals out of the society.
  • Deterrance - thieves have hands cut off so they won't steal, and murderers will be executed so they don't murder.
6 of 23

What are Non-Religious arguments against Capital

Punishment?

  • No court can be 100% sure that the verdict is correct. Wrongly convicted people can be released from prison, but not if they have been executed.
  • Murderers regard life imprisonment as worse than death.
  • Murderers who know they will be killed if caught are more likely to kill more people to avoid being caught.
  • Statistics of people killing in countries without the death penalty are lower than in countries with it.
7 of 23

What are the 4 Theories of Punishment?

  • Retribution - criminals should be punished.
  • Reform - changing criminals so they don't commit crimes again.
  • Protection - prevent society from criminals.
  • Deterrance - put people off committing crimes
8 of 23

Why is justice important for Muslims?

  • Qur'an says God is just so will reward and punish on the last day.
  • Qur'an says all Muslims should treat people fairly.
  • Part of their role as vice-gerents of God's creation to treat all people fairly.
  • Unjust to charge interest (riba) as it takes money from the poor and gives it to the rich.
9 of 23

Why is justice important for Christians?

  • Bible - God is just and will reward the righteous and punish those who sin.
  • Bible - people should be treated fairly and God wants the world to be ruled justly.
  • Jesus said the rich should share with the poor. Christians should treat people fairly and equally.
  • World Council of Churches Assembly (Vancouver 1984) invited Christian communities to help the process of 'Justice, peace and the integrity of creation'
10 of 23

Why do some Muslims oppose Capital Punishment?

  • recommended by the Qur'an, but not compulsory.
  • Shari'ah says that the family of a murder victim can accept blood money from the murderer instead of death.
  • Agree with the non-religious arguments against Capital Punishment (2)
11 of 23

What are the UK laws on Tobacco?

  • Illegal to sell cigarettes, cigars, tobacco etc. to under 18's.
  • All tobacco packs must have big health warnings and picture warnings about the effect of smoking.
  • Adverts and sponsorship for tobacco is banned.
  • Illegal to smoke indoor public places, workplaces, football grounds and all parts of railway stations.
12 of 23

What are the UK laws on Alcohol?

  • Illegal to give an alcoholic drink to under 5's.
  • Children under 16 can go into a pub but can't have alcoholic drinks.
  • People aged 16 or 17 can drink beer, wine or cider with a meal, if bought and accompanied by an adult.
  • Illegal for under 18s to buy alcohol anywhere.
13 of 23

What are the UK laws on Illegal Drugs?

It is an offence to:

  • Possess a controlled substance with intent to supply or offer to supply a controlled drug.
  • Possess a controlled substance unlawfully.
  • Allow your premises to be used for drug taking.

controlled - class A, B or C drugs

14 of 23

What are the Health Problems caused by Tobacco?

  • Smoking increases risk of more than 50 health conditions.
  • Smoking causes various cancers, coronary heart disease; stroke, chronic bronchitis and emphysema.
  • In men, smoking can cause impotence.
  • In pregnant women who smoke, their babies will have a lower birth weight, will be weaker and may not develop normally.
15 of 23

What are the Health Problems caused by Alcohol?

  • If you drink heavily, you have an increased risk of developing serious health conditions - liver problems, stomach disorders, heart disease and some cancers.
  • Heavy drinking can lead to addiction.
  • About 1 in 7 deaths are caused by effects of drinking alcohol.
16 of 23

What are the Health Problems caused by Illegal

Drugs?

  • Physical health of users can be damaged because of the toxic effects of a drug.
  • Can cause death by infections, liver disease or intentional self harm.
  • Heavy users often have psychiatric illnesses.
17 of 23

What are the Social Problems caused by Drugs and A

Alcohol - 

  • 50% of fire deaths are caused by the effects of alcohol
  • 70% of murder victims and 40% of **** offenders had been drinking at the time of the incident.
  • 50% of sex abuse crimes are done by someone who abuses alcohol.

Illegal Drugs - 

  • High cost of heroin or cocaine habit forces users into a life of crime.
  • All drug dealers are criminals, leads to violence between different gangs of suppliers.
18 of 23

What do all Christians believe about Illegal Drugs

AGAINST DRUGS 

  • They are illegal and they abuse the body which is thought of as God's temple.
19 of 23

What do most Christians believe about Tobacco and

Alcohol and why?

MODERATION:

  • The first miracle that Jesus performed was turning water into wine at a wedding feast.
  • Jesus uses bread and wine at the Last Supper and told the disciples to continue the tradition.
  • Most Churches use alcoholic wine in their Communion services.
  • St Paul said that Christians could drink in moderation.
20 of 23

What do some Christians believe about Tobacco and

Alcohol and why?

REFUSE (Salvation Army, Methodists, Pentecostals):

  • Using tobacco and alcohol is abusing God's temple (their bodies).
  • Bible passages warn against drunkenness.
  • Bible teaches that consumption of alcohol damages judgement, inflames passions and invites violence.
  • Many Christians are involved in working with alcoholics and want to support them by refusing alcohol.
21 of 23

What do all Muslims believe about Drugs and Alcoho

PROHIBITED (HARAM):

  • Qur'an says that intoxicants are a way that Satan tries to keep people from God and from saying their prayers.
  • Prophet Muhammed said that every intoxicant is forbidden to Muslims (khamr)
  • Muslim lawyers say taking drugs or alcohol is a form of suicide (harming the body) and suicide is forbidden.
  • Muhammed said that Muslims mustn't drink alcohol or have anything to do with the production and sale of alcohol.
22 of 23

What do Muslims believe about Tobacco and why?

HARAM - harms the body

MAKRUH (lawyers think this) - because it is not mentionned by the Qur'an or Muhammad.

23 of 23

Comments

No comments have yet been made

Similar Religious Studies resources:

See all Religious Studies resources »See all Crime and Punishment resources »