After a Guilty Verdict
Imprisonment, Alternatives and Treatment
- Created by: Laura
- Created on: 17-06-11 10:22
Imprisonment
Planned Behaviours
Gillis et al
Imprisonment
59% of prisoners discharged from prison reconvivted (1998)
investigated effects of community-based employment scheme on recidivism rates
over 20,000 - 95% males - mostly drug-realted crimes or fraud
Experimental group had completed employment programme and secured job, control group hadn't.
Experimental group volunteered selves for programme (already willing to change)
70% experimental group remained out of prison, 55% control group so employment programmes work to reduce likelihood of reoffending
Offenders with less chance of getting job due to poor education etc should be put on such programmes to help them plan life on release and reduce recidivism
Imprisonment
Depression/Suicide Risk
Dooley
Imprisonment
92 unnatural deaths in prisons in 2007 and 100 resuscitations. 1500 on suice watch - one factor is age and gender (young men most at risk) and another factor is overcrowding
Looked at all unnatural deaths in prsions over 15 years (longitudinal)
442 unnatural deaths and 52 self-inflicted injuries
Most of suicide group on remand and most of self-inflicted group were females.
Deaths occurred mostly at night - extra watches during night to prevent this?
Study helps put into perspective level of suicide in prison which is much higherthan previous years and isuseful in giving ideas how to reduce this i.e. reduce overcrowding to prevent stress from lack of privacy etc.
Imprisonment
Prison Situation
and Roles
Zimbardo
Imprisonment
Split prisoners into prisoners and guards
Guards became sadistic and prisoners became depressed
One prisoner displayed symptoms of disorganised thinking, uncontrollable crying and screaming and another developed psychosomatic rash
In overcrowded prisons, prisoners display signs of learnt helplessness i.e. stop behaving both good and bad
Alternatives to Imprisonment
Probation
Mair and May
Alternative to Imprisonment
Offenders on probation given questionnaires about their life, likelihood of reoffending and attitudes towards probation
88% found probation useful and most effective part was having someone to talk to about problems like housing and work
Only 37% believed probation would stop them reoffending but not one offender thought it was designed to prevent reoffending
1/3 went on to commit another offence
Suggests that although probation seen in positive light by prisoners, it doesn't have a huge impact on recidivism and are unaware of purpose
Alternatives to Imprisonment
Resorative Justice
Sherman and Strang
Alternatives to Imprisonment
Offender encouraged to accept responsibility for crime and be re-integrated into society.
Offender meets victim to increase victim empathy and learn how crime has effected them - can also help the victim deal with their anger/feelings
First time petty offences - may be offered as alternative to prison and more serious offences - may be part of sentence
Results of research showed significant reductions in re-offending for property and violent crimes but didn't work as well for other crimes - may be as violence/property crimes affect someone personally whereas stealing from large retail chain doesn't
Restorative justice is useful alternative for certain types of crim but use is limited
Alternatives to Imprisonment
Looking Deathworthy
Eberhardt
Alternatives to Imprisonment
some people may be more likely to receive death penalty in America based on what they look like
Results showed black people 57% more likely to receivedeath penalty whereas less stereotypically black people only 25%
Where victim was white more likely to receive death penalty than if victim is black
Treatment
Cognitive Skills Programme
Friendship et al
Treatment
similar to CBT - aimed at changing thinking patterns BUT takes long time and must be continual
670 male offenders (androcentric but large sample) volunteered to participate (already willing to chance - validity issues?)
Programme involves reasoning and rehabilitation and enhanced thinking skills to correct faulty thinking patterns linked to offending beahviour
Results showed significant drop in reconviction rates - up to 14% lower than control group
This reduction represents prevention of 21,000 crimes
Treatment
Anger Management
Ireland
Treatment
Similar to SIT -
- Cognitive preparation - what makes them angry?
- Skills acquisition - taught skills like relaxation to cope with anger
- Application - put into practice situations to help practice applying skills
92% of prisoners showed improvement and no change in behaviours of control group
BUT long term effectiveness not yet established and little data to compare this with other treatments
Treatment
Ear Accupuncture &
Drug Rehabilitation
Wheatley
Treatment
350 prisoners in 6 high security prisons received ear accupuncture to treat drug addictions and make prisoners calmer
Prisoners reported better sleep and improved relaxation, better coping skills, reduced nicotine cravings and improved health
Staff reported wings were calmer
- 70% reduction in drug-realted incidents
- 41% reduction in serious incidents
- 42% reduction in positive drug testing
Accupuncture does work to reduce drug behaviours in prisons and calm prisonersdown BUT doesn't adress behaviours once they have left prison so needs longitudinal research to discover this
Comments
Report