Piaget vs. Vygotsky

?
  • Created by: Shannon
  • Created on: 12-01-15 17:03

Piaget

Vygotsky's Sociocultural Development Theory

  • Exquilibration - Achieving balance between thought processes and environment.
  • Constructivism - Children are active agents as they construct their own knowledge of reality.
  • Schemas - Organised patterns of thought to interpret processes.
  • Cognitive schemas: Sensorimotor (0-2) - infants know through overt actions. Constructivism (3-7): children can think about objects and events without acting on them. Operational (7+): children use cognitive operations; many of these correspond to mathematical symbols and show reversibility.
  • Organisation: combining existing schemas promotes ADAPTATION.
  • ADAPTATION: Adjusting to the environment consists of: ASSIMILATION (interpreting new experiences in terms of existing knowledge and ACCOMMODATION (modifying existing schemas to account for new information)
  • SENSORIMOTOR STAGE (0-2): Reflexes at birth, primary circular actions on own body (1-4mths), Secondary circular actions unintentional repetitive actions on external objects(4-8mths), Co-ordination of secondary schemes intentional integration of 2 responses (8-12mths), Tertiary circular reactions is the experimentation with objects (12-18mths), Symbolic problem solving is inner experimentation and internalisation of schemes. Tools user with prior knowledge rather than trial and error (18-24mths). OBJECT PERMANENCE: b, b>c, then a is the biggest. HORIZONTAL DECALAGE: tasks requiring similar operations are easier than others.
  • FORMAL OPERATIONAL (11+): Even some adult are not proficient in this stage. Mental actions on ideas and propositions. Best performance in familiar contexts.
  • CRITICISM: 1. Tests too difficult for children to express knowledge 2. infants not surprised when they fail a-not-b task. 3. Children not always egocentric as it depends on task (Hughes, 1975). 4. Animalism only in context where novel object appears to move by itself. 5. Ignores role of sociocultural factors.
  • Microgenetic development: over brief periods (days)
  • Ontogenetic development: over a lifetime
  • Phylogenetic development: over lifetime of species (evolutionary)
  • Sociohistorical: historical changes in culture/values
  • Infants born with few elementary mental functions. These are transformed into higher mental functions through culture's provision of mental tool adaptation. i.e. children taught what to think through culture's values.
  • Active learners, not solitary explorers
  • Use internalised instructions to control behaviour and cognitions.
  • Scaffolding: Teacher begins teaching at a level child will comprehend, but builds on it, then when knowledge is achieved, steps back and offers help as required.
  • Guided Participation: Informal tutoring of cultural practices in non-industrialised societies.
  • Context independent learning: The way of teaching children in westernised schools
  • Talking when nobody is listening irrelevant in early years, but becomes more poignant as child gets older and is a cognitive self-guidance system.
  • STRENGTHS: 1. evidence for social interactions across cultures incorporate joint play and tuition within children’s zone of proximal development. 2. Evidence for self-directed speech is functional in behaviour regulation,especially for difficult tasks. 3. Lacks detail due to premature death.
  • PROXIMAL ZONE of DEVELOPMENT: difference between what a learner can do without help and what he or she can do with help.

Comments

No comments have yet been made