RS - Problem of Evil
- Created by: queerokapi
- Created on: 27-04-19 13:09
View mindmap
- The Problem of Evil
- the evidential problem of evil
- why is there SO MUCH evil if there has to be some?
- William Rowe's examples of pointless suffering
- the man who kills, beats and rapes his girlfriends daughter
- a fawn dies slowly and alone after a forest fire
- the logical problem of evil
- the inconsistent triad (epicurus)
- God is omnibenevolent
- "a wholly good being eliminates evil as far as it can" J.L. Mackie
- God is omnipotent
- Evil Exists
- a version of the irenaean theodicy
- "is he both able and willing? then whence cometh evil?"
- God is omnibenevolent
- the inconsistent triad (epicurus)
- "evil is the rock of atheism" Hume
- defenses of God/Theodicies
- Aquinas
- divine goodness is different to human goodness
- John Hick's Soul making theodicy
- modern version of the Iranean Theodicy
- we have to perfect ourselves (in his image vs in his likeness)
- "Let Us make man in Our image, according to Our likeness" Genesis, Bible
- " intrinsically more valuable than virtues created within him ready made without effort on his own part"
- diminishes role of Jesus as Messiah
- otherwise we'd just be very moral robots
- the world is "rather well adapted to the quite different purpose of soul making"
- evil matters more
- "only in such a world can mutual caring and love be elicited"
- evil matters more
- if you don't do it in this life, you get reincarnated and can try again
- your actions don't matter?
- explains why we can't know God -
- we'd have to obey him - like driving with a policeman in the back seat
- Free will defence
- Søren Kierkegaard's parable of the king and the peasant girl
- Richard Swinburne - God can't prevent serious moral evil without restricting choice
- "we are asking [...] that God should make a toy world, a world where things matter, but not very much"
- weaknesses
- J.L Mackie - could create beings that always chose good
- John Hick says these would be no more free than robots
- Peter Vardy - what about natural evil?
- determinists - we don't have free will, it is all cause and effect
- love can never be expressed through pain (D.Z Phillips)
- J.L Mackie - could create beings that always chose good
- Process Thought (not a theodicy)
- based on work by A.N. Whitehead but created by David Griffin
- hebrew translation of bible "when God began to create the heavens and the earth, the earth was without form"
- God created the world out of Chaos and can't control natural laws
- HE IS NOT OMNIPOTENT
- "God is the fellow sufferer" A.N Whitehead
- Brian Davis - God is also "In the soup"
- "God cannot coerce worldly beings because the inherent power they have cannot be overriden" David Griffin
- makes you feel at one with God
- is this a God worth worshipping?
- like a father - the holy trinity
- HE IS NOT OMNIPOTENT
- God created the world out of Chaos and can't control natural laws
- Aquinas
- suffering is unevenly distributed
- the brothers Karamazov (novel written by Fydor Dostoyevsky to talk about philosophy through fictional characters)
- "It's not God that I don't accept, Alyosha, only I most respectfully return him the ticket [to heaven]”
- Ivan Karamzov (fictional) believed we shouldn't accept favour from a God who causes such suffering
- "It's not God that I don't accept, Alyosha, only I most respectfully return him the ticket [to heaven]”
- augustinian theodicy
- God created the world good but it went bad bc of original sin
- the evidential problem of evil
Comments
No comments have yet been made