Physiological approach

Studies in approach?
Maguire, Dement & Kleitman, Sperry
1 of 78
Maguire aim?
To investigate the difference in the hippocampi of London taxi drivers compared to controls.
2 of 78
Navigation experience
3 of 78
What was the research method? why?
Quasi - naturally occuring IV
4 of 78
Sample? (experimental)
experimental group - 16 London taxi drivers, 32-62 years old, right handed, passed 'the knowledge', healthy medically, neurologically, psychologically.
5 of 78
Sample? (control)
Control group - non-taxi drivers, researchers selected 50 scans from MRI database, healthy right handed males, 32-62 years old.
6 of 78
Why were taxi drivers considered excellent subjects for the study?
They had increased environmental demands on their spatial memory, as they acquired 'the knowledge'.
7 of 78
What 2 techniques were used to analyse data from structural MRI scans?
VBM, Pixel counting
8 of 78
What is VBM?
A 3 dimensional measurement of grey matter volume, indicates general brain differences.
9 of 78
What is pixel counting?
2 dimensional measurement of posterior, body & anterior of hippocampus by one person experienced in the technique.
10 of 78
Why did Maguire use 2 techniques?
VBM was new so couldnt rely, used older method & compared results (triangulation).
11 of 78
Results of anterior (front)
Controls had higher cross-sectional area (mm2) than taxi drivers.
12 of 78
Posterior results?
Taxi drivers had higher posterior volume.
13 of 78
Body results?
Taxi drivers had larger body of hippocampi.
14 of 78
Pixel counting results?
Revealed no difference in overall volume of hippocampus, but significant difference in L & R side of hippocampus between taxi drivers & controls.
15 of 78
What were the 2 co-variables of the study?
VBM analysis of hippocampal volume, time spent as a taxi driver.
16 of 78
Reason for correlational analysis?
Allows to see change over time because an MRI scan is only oone moment.
17 of 78
what were the results? Positive correlation between...
volume of grey matter in right posterior hippocampus and time spent learning to be a licensed London taxi driver.
18 of 78
Negative correlation between...
volume of grey matter in right anterior hippocampus & time spent learning to be a London taxi driver.
19 of 78
What do the results tell us?
Posterior hippocampus larger in taxi drivers to accommodate their knowledge & mental map of London layout.
20 of 78
How does it support the nurture debate?
We can shape our brains by increasing our knowledge in a specific area to make parts of the brain larger.
21 of 78
Upheld ehitcs?
Consent, withdraw, deception, harm, confidentiality, debrief.
22 of 78
Broken ethics?
withdraw - difficult in MRI, Harm - claustrophobia in scan.
23 of 78
EV - high & low?
High - normal jobs, Low - having brain scanned
24 of 78
x2 problems?
Only used m pp's, cross-sectional data only looks at one point in their lives (repeat every 5 years).
25 of 78
Dement & Kleitman Focus?
The relation of eye movements during sleep to dream.
26 of 78
27 of 78
Different stages of sleep & brain activity shown by EEG, NREM (stages 1-4), REM.
28 of 78
What does EEG, EOG, EMG measure?
EEG - brain activity, EOG - eye movement, EMG - muscle moement
29 of 78
What is REM?
rapid eye movement
30 of 78
7 males, 2 females, 5 studied intensely, 4 to confirm findings.
31 of 78
What were the 6 controls?
Slept in lab before usual bedtime, woken by doorbell, not allowed alcohol/caffeine, eat normally throughout day, speak into tape recorder, no contact with experimenter.
32 of 78
What was the role of the EEG machine?
Identify stage of sleep pp in & length of stage.
33 of 78
First research Q?
Whether significant association between REM & dreaming.
34 of 78
Woken in REM/NEM.
35 of 78
Report of having dream/not
36 of 78
Data type?
37 of 78
2nd research Q?
whether relationship between length & time in REM & dream length.
38 of 78
woken at 5/15mins into REM sleep
39 of 78
dream length & content compared to REM duration
40 of 78
3rd research Q?
Whether relationship between eye movement pattern & dream content
41 of 78
pps woken 1 min after eye movement
42 of 78
content of dream
43 of 78
Data type?
44 of 78
REM results? of hypoth 1?
152 dreams, 39 non-dreams
45 of 78
NREM resutls?
11 dreams, 149 non dreams
46 of 78
Hypoth 2 results after 5 mins of REM?
45 correct dream duration, 6 incorrect
47 of 78
After 15 mins?
47 correct, 13 incorrect
48 of 78
Hypoth 3 results?
Vertical eye movement - standing at bottom of cliff, looking up at climbers
49 of 78
Dreamer watching 2 people throwing tomatoes at eachother.
50 of 78
looking for something/fighting
51 of 78
Watching from distacne/fixed object.
52 of 78
Research method?
Lab experiment
53 of 78
Upheld ethics?
Consent, Deception, Withdraw, Debrief, Confidentiality, Harm
54 of 78
Deception (weren't told woken in non REM), Harm (fatigue)
55 of 78
High EV?
sleeping normal time in dark room
56 of 78
Low EV?
woken in lab, wires, tape record dream, no caffeine/alcohol.
57 of 78
x2 problems
uneven number m & f, low EV
58 of 78
Sperry, Focus?
Hemispheric deconnection
59 of 78
Two hemispheres of brain control activity on opposite side of body
60 of 78
Left hemisphere controls?
Language & maths
61 of 78
Right hemisphere controls?
Spatial awareness & emotion
62 of 78
To study effects of hemispheric deconnection & functions of separated hempisheres.
63 of 78
Research method?
Quasi experiment
64 of 78
What is the corpus callosum?
nerves linking two sides of brain
65 of 78
11 patients, had severe epilepsy, had previously undergone a commisurotomy.
66 of 78
Two task types?
Visual & Tactile
67 of 78
Ethics upheld?
68 of 78
Harm - could've caused distress
69 of 78
High EV?
Seeing & touching everyday objects
70 of 78
Low EV?
Using one visual field for 1/10 sec.
71 of 78
x2 problems?
Small sample, one point in time.
72 of 78
Section C, main assumption?
All that is psychological is first physiological, since the mind appears to reside in the brain, all thoughts, feelings & behaviours ultimately have a physiological cause.
73 of 78
An implication?
Psychology should study the brain, nervous system and other biological factors.
74 of 78
DK & Sperry use small samples
75 of 78
DK lab, Sperry Quasi
76 of 78
x2 strengths of approach?
often uses highly controlled research methods & tests, provides a precise way of measuring & gives valid results.
77 of 78
x2 weaknesses?
Overly reductionist - focuses purely on biological factors affecting behaviour & ignores influence of nurture & cognitions. Often relies on lab experiement method - lacks EV.
78 of 78

Other cards in this set

Card 2


Maguire aim?


To investigate the difference in the hippocampi of London taxi drivers compared to controls.

Card 3




Preview of the front of card 3

Card 4


What was the research method? why?


Preview of the front of card 4

Card 5


Sample? (experimental)


Preview of the front of card 5
View more cards


No comments have yet been made

Similar Psychology resources:

See all Psychology resources »See all Psychology case studies resources »