Is the concept of life after death meaningful within itself?
Flew - The concept is contradictory. You cannot witness your own funeral. "Surviving death" is meaningless and contradictory.
Schlick - Conceivable that you could witness your own funeral
Flew - What one is witnessing is not "oneself" but your body, an empty shell.
Where is the continuity?
Mackay - Chalk message written on a blackboard could be rubbed out and…