Credibility INFLATION - childs testimony is enhanced because of them being protected from negative effects of trauma. Credibility DEFLATION - child witness is seen as unreliable because of the use of a shield.
Aim; 1) if use of protective shields and videotape testimony increases the likelihood of a guilty verdict 2) investigate effect of protective devices on jury reaction to testimony do they experience credibility inflation or credibility deflation.
Method; mock trial based on a real court case. ACTORS USED. X3 conditions. 1 - open court 2 - child behind 4x6ft screen 3 - childs testimony via videolink. (p's 100 to each condition).
Procedure; Ech group watched 2 hour film of case of alleged abuse of childs father accused of single touch whilst bathing. Judge told not to imply guilt by form of testimony drawing attention to the aim.
Results; 1 - 51% guilty, 49% not guilty, 2 - 46% guilty 54% not guilty, 3 - 49% guilty 51% not guilty. Conclusion; Results suggest victim is not more at risk at the defendent being found not guilty if protective devices are used, shows best thing to do is a video link.
Comments
No comments have yet been made