Virtue Ethics - Strengths + Weaknesses
- Created by: ameliaden98
- Created on: 24-02-16 19:08
Virtue Ethics - Strength
Agent-centred
You could have moral theory which may seem good, but have absurd consequences if you always follow it
E.g. moral theory to always tell the truth - problem if axe-murderer asks you where your children are
Virtue ethics sys you don't need to follow theory, but rather become virtuous so you simply know
We don't get the problem of the masses just mindlessly following dictactorship
Virtue Ethics - Strength
Improved people by developing character
It does not just tell you to be good, but rather teaches you how to be good
Normative theories (e.g. Kantian ethics) give you a theory on how to be good, but you don't have to be a good person to follow a theory
Virtue Ethics - Strength
It motivates you to be good
In order to do good actions, you have to be a good person
With normative ethics, you are not encouraged to cultivate anything
With virtue ethics, you are encouraged to cultivate yourself and virtues
Virtue Ethics - Strength
Holistic
Concerned with the whole person
Involves our whole life, as we are always able to find an opportunity to develop a particular virtue
Virtue Ethics - Strength
With this theory we are able to distinguish good people from legalists
Just because someone follows the rules, it does not mean they are a virtuous person
Virtue Ethics - Strength
Enables us to integrate many aspects of our life into our ethical reflection
For example, it does not reject our emotions, but rather includes them
It is more aware of how people naturally react to ethical dilemmas
Virtue Ethics - Strength
It has a focus on encouraging us to want to be a good person
Encourages idea that good actions are their own reward
Advocates idea that we ought to look to people we view as good to develop our own virtues
Virtue Ethics - Strength
Does not claim to know what to do in any situation
Contrastingly, it encourages us to be a more virtuous person, so that we will simply know what to do in a particular situation
No need to refer to a normative ethical theory
Virtue Ethics - Weaknesses
It is difficult to identify what the virtues are
There is a definite sense that our idea of virtues depend on cultural upbringing and social conditioning
This is problematic as we have no way of knowing if we are actually being virtuous, or if are actions are merely viceful
MacIntyre allows for some relativism, but this seems weak
Virtue Ethics - Weaknesses
Robert Louden
States that Virtue ethics does not help people facing ethical dilemmas
It does not give any clear course of action, or any rules
One response from a virtue ethicist may be that we would not need rules if everyone is virtuous
This is a massive assumption, as we are not all going to be virtuous
Virtue Ethics - Weaknesses
Robert Loudon
Difficult for us to decide who is virtuous
Virtue ethics encourages us to look to people we admire for guidance (particularly Michael Slote's virtue ethics), but we have no way of knowing if such people are actually virtuous
People could do seemingly virtuous actions, but have bad intentions
Virtue Ethics - Weaknesses
You could have conflicting virtues
A virtue ethicist may respond saying that the truly virtuous perosn will just know what to do
But this is a weak response - it does not help someone still working towards being virtuous
E.g. obeying the law vs. being loyal to a loved one
Virtue Ethics - Weaknesses
Problematic in the fact that it seems to praise some virtues we may deem immoral
For example, you could say courage is a virtue, but a soldier courageously fighting in an unjust war does not make the soldier morally good
You could counter this argument by referring to Aristotle's "Golden Mean", or other virtue ethicists' ideas that virtues are not virtues all the time
Virtue Ethics - Weaknesses
It does not seem to have room for basic concepts, such as rights and obligations
Therefore, it seems incapable of dealing with big issues, as it does not always have a view about whether something is right or wrong
No robust idea of what is right or wrong
Virtue Ethics - Weaknesses
It depends on there being some final end, or purpose which gives shape to our lives
There may be no eudaimonia, or anything to the equivalent, meaning striving towards it is pointless
Even if there is some "telos" to human life, there is nothing to suggest that being virtuous is the best way to reach it
Also, not everyone may want to be virtuous
Related discussions on The Student Room
- AQA A-level Religious Studies 1 (7062/1) 12 Jun & 2 (7062/2A-2E) 19 Jun [Exam Chat] »
- AQA A Level Philosophy Paper 1 + 2 (7172/1+2) 18th and 26th May 2023 [Exam Chat] »
- Aqa a level philosophy and ethics paper 1 (rs) 2023 »
- AQA A Level Philosophy Paper 1 7172/1 - 19 May 2022 [Exam Chat] »
- Edexcel A-level Religious Studies Paper 1 (9RS0 01) - 12th June 2023 [Exam Chat] »
- OCR A-Level Religious Studies Paper 2 (H573/02) 19th June 2023 [Exam Chat] »
- Edexcel A-Level Religious Studies June 12,19,26th »
- CCEA Religious Studies. GCSE and A-Level thread »
- Religious studies eduqas A-level A02 30 marker structure help »
- Can you just talk about weaknesses for 16 markers? »
Comments
No comments have yet been made