TOPIC 3: Critical criminology
0.0 / 5
- Created by: xemilygraceyx
- Created on: 03-05-16 09:22
The traditional Marxist approach - 1
The basis of criminal law
- Little to steal for poor
- Personal violence = dangerous
- Ruling class wish to control right to use violence in society through agents
- Law operates to protect rich and powerful
Law creation and dominant hegemony
- Number of agencies used to impose ruling class values on masses
- Forms framework on which laws are based in democracy
- Marxists = values 'forced' on people
- What they believe they are agreeing to as result of own beliefs = interests of ruling class
Law enforcement
- Provide benefits for population if applied fairly
- Law not enforced against ruling class
1 of 11
The traditional Marxist approach - 2
Individual motivation
- Bonger (1916) = capitalism based on competition/selfishness/greed --> formed people's attitudes
- Poor people driven to crime by desperate conditions
Crime and control
- Ruling class diverts attention of vast majority away from understanding of true causes of situation
- Impose values through mass media/education system/etc. --> provide alternative accounts of reality
- Crime diverts attention away from exploitative nature of capitalism --> focuses attention on frightening nature of certain criminal groups
- E.g. heavy policing, 'stop and searches', etc.
2 of 11
Criticisms of Marxist approach
- Stephen Jones = activities of capitalists sometimes criminalised --> not always true that law favours ruling classes
- Left realists = Marxists put undue emphasis on corporate crime at expense of other types of crime, victims of crimes ignored by Marxism
- Explanation of law creation/enforcement = too simplistic --> no allowance made for complexity of processes of law making/competing groups who exert pressure on governments to amend/create laws
3 of 11
The New Criminology
- Wider origins of deviant act = 1970s was period of social crisis in Britain, result of international downturn in capitalist economies
- Immediate origins of deviant act = riots, conflict in Northern Ireland, high level of strikes, government searching for group to scapegoat
- Actual act = Mugging more likely to be carried out by people from A-C backgrounds
- Immediate origins of social reaction = Media outrage - linked to racism
- Wider origins of social reaction = need to find scapegoats/ease with which young men from A-C backgrounds could be blamed
- Outcome of social reaction on deviants' further action = sense of injustice amongst ethnic minorities, loss of confidence by ethnic-minority communities
- Nature of deviant process as whole = real causes not addressed, hidden by CJS
4 of 11
New left realism
- Critical of other theories
- Accuse traditional Marxists of having idealistic views of criminals as political revolutionaries fighting back against capitalism
- Crime is serious problem = victims ignored by Marxists --> often working classes
- Traditional Marxists criticised for implying that perpetrators of crime are heroes rebelling against ruling classes
- Official stats = broadly correct, not just social constructs
- Accept that policing policies may exaggerate ethnic minority crime rate
5 of 11
Evaluation of New Criminology
- Traditional Marxists scathing of Left Realists who openly want to help governments to reduce crime
- Capitalism itself is cause of crime
- Marxists criticise Left Realism/New Criminology for placing too much emphasis on street crime - not enough on white collar crime
- Gordon Hughes (1991) = New Left realism focuses more on victims of crime, balanced theory
- Feminists = no discussion of power of patriarchy/how patriarchy has profound implications for impact of crime in women's lives
6 of 11
Marxist subcultural theory
- Working class boys may join gangs as form of resistance to capitalism
- Disadvantaged under capitalism
- Joining gangs offers solution to unemployment/low status work
'The Centre for Contemporary Cultural Studies':
- Capitalism maintains control by ideological dominance through media
- Economic pressures - people want to keep their jobs/pay mortgages
Brake:
- Resistance expressed through working-class youth subcultures
- Clothes/language show disdain of capitalism
- 'Magical' = form of illusion
- Society changes constantly = every generation experiences very different world --> majority will always be exploited by ruling class
7 of 11
Evaluation of Marxist subcultural theory
- Matza = young men drift in and out of criminal activity --> looking for excitement, search for subterranean values
- Interactionists = young men targeted/picked on by police --> process labelling
- Traditional Marxists = real criminals are corporate criminals, CJS is biased
- Blackman = emphasis on working-class basis of subcultural resistance ignores huge variation of subcultures --> based on variations in sexual identity/locality/age/intellectual capacity
8 of 11
Crimes of the state
- Herman Schwendinger = definitions of state crimes should be extended to include human rights crimes
- Violation of people's human rights should be defined as illegal/criminal
- If some groups are denied same opportunities as majority population on basis of racism/sexism/homophobia/economically exploited = unequal conditions are result of crimes against human rights
- Cohen = criticises Schwendinger --> genocide/torture are clearly crimes, economic exploitation is not clearly criminal
- Not enough agreement as to what constitutes human rights
- Schwendinger confusing immorality with criminality --> taking a highly moral value position
Ross: crimes committed by state -
- Committed within particular country/those by one country on another
- Between direct and indirect actions of state apparatus
- Between crimes of commission and omission
9 of 11
Crimes of the state - 2
- Indirect state crime = through agencies that are not directly controlled, e.g. police
- Direct state crime = failing to undertake activities which lead to grave consequences for citizens
Barak (1991): how do states commit crimes in other countries?
- USA interfered in political processes of Central/South American countries --> ensure that interests of large US corporations safeguarded
- Activities of US government = supporting rebel groups etc.
Tombs and Whyte: why are crimes of the state rarely discussed?
- Research in Britain increasingly 'policy oriented' --> state agencies asking for very specific pieces of research
- Difficult to get conclusions widely distributed
- Extremely difficult to gain access to more powerful groups --> power to deny access
10 of 11
Problems of solving crimes of states
- States define what is criminal within own boundaries --> 'viewpoints'
- Standard of 'human rights' - state accused of 'crimes of the state' if country breaks internationally agreed 'human rights'
- States able to prevent sociologists studying whole issue = restricting access to information, refusing to fund research, threats etc.
- Barak = failure of US government to provide adequate social-security payments/lack of federal healthcare system --> viewed as breach of human rights/state crime
11 of 11
Related discussions on The Student Room
- Prepare for a career in the criminal justice sector »
- Level 3 Criminology Research »
- AQA A Level Sociology Paper 3 7192/3 - 13 Jun 2022 [Exam Chat] »
- School distance »
- OCR A-level Sociology Paper 3 (H580/03) - 14th June 2023 [Exam Chat] »
- AQA A Level Sociology Paper 3 (7192/3) - 14th June [Exam Chat] »
- Sociology Help Thread »
- Sociology A Level?? »
- AQA A Level Sociology Paper 3 (7192/3) - 11th June 2024 [Exam Chat] »
- Criminology At University »
Similar Sociology resources:
0.0 / 5
0.0 / 5
0.0 / 5
0.0 / 5
5.0 / 5 based on 2 ratings
0.0 / 5
0.0 / 5
0.0 / 5
0.0 / 5
Comments
No comments have yet been made