Additionally, Freud argued that religion is an obsessional neurosis. It provides a way for people to satisfy their desires, such as that the world would be ordered and life be meaningful.
The answers religion give are appealing, such as the rewards in heaven. Therefore although the Summum Bonum being achievable is a very persuasive human desire, this in no way makes it, or God, a reality.
If Freud is correct, then Kant's claim that morality is objective and discovered through reason is vulnerable. Freud would argue that morality is the product of society and upbringing, and not something to be desired. Thus, if this is true, Kant's argument for God's existence as a postulate of pure practical reason fails.
Comments
Report