Stalin's Five Year Plans: The Second Five Year Plan (January 1933- December 1937)
- Created by: _awesome_E
- Created on: 10-01-15 09:43
The Second Five Year Plan
This was a more realistic version of the first five year plan with better production targets that were more realistic and there was a greater attempt to develop a rounded economy.
The second year plan was between January 1933- December 1937
The Priorities of the Second Five Year Plans
Initally it promised living conditions would improve, yet famine in the countryside meant rations had to continue until 1934
From 1934-36 a larger effort was made, yet this changed due to the re-armament of Germany, military spending repalced any focus on consumer goods
Continued to focus on heavy industries, but also concerned about consolitating the problems from the first year plan
Tried to stimulate growth of new industries, e.g. chemical processing and development of new materials
Improve the Russian transport links
Schemes put in place to increase productivity, with insentives and new codes of practice which set high expectations of labour performance
Reasons for Changes in Priorities
Senior figures in the soviet governement aware of the failings of the first five year plan
From 1932, a group of party leaders led by Sergei Kirov argued for a better standard of living for industrial workers
The problem with the first year plan was that they were unable to transport the vast amounts of raw materials produced
Improving transport infrastructure became a priority
The moderates also argued that governement need the peasants support, if war was iminent due to Hilter becoming chancellor
Governments should try to win back peasants by reforming collective farms and the Anti-Kulak policy
Following Kirov's murder in 1934, the moderates lost their influence with amny being arrested, executed or staying quiet during the 1936 purges
The final revised second five year plan also responded to the threat of war
Stalin revised the plan so to diverted funds away from consumer goods production to invest in Russia's miltary resources instead
The Stakhanovite Movement
First Plan revealed weaknesses in Russia's labour force, productivity and discipline in factories was low, holding back economic growth
The solution was to launch a new propaganda campaign appealing to the heroic instincts of the Russia people, offering insentives to those who worked over their quota
The governement created a media legend, Alexi Stakhanov, who according to the media could mine 102 tonnes of coal in 6 hours, 14 times the normal output in August 1935
A month later he excelled his record, mining 227 tonnes in one day, he was rewarded heavily, recieving: A new apartment with a telephone, a months wages, and tickets to the cinema/theatre
The message was simple- Work hard and get rewarded
Compulsory meetings were organised, workers encouraged to be like Stakhanov
Bosses had to keep a record of production totals and re-organise production technique to facilitate growth
What happened was no accident it was all planned in to the second plan, emphaisis on labour productivity
However Stakhanov's legend inspired workers and in doing so increased productivity
Achievements of the Second Five Year Plan
Targets were more realistic than the first, so its achivements were more modest
Governement claimed the sencond plan had been 'over-fulfilled' by 3%
Production of raw materials continued to expand e.g. output in steel trebled, due to production of new plants
Transport also had some successes, the first lines of the Moscow Metro were opened in 1935
Moscow-Volga Canal was completed between 1932-1937, allowing the transportation of large quantites of material throughout Europe
Living standards had some successes, starting with the end of Bread rationing in 1934, later follwed by the end to other rationing e.g. meat and butter
Wages of industrial workers increased and reforms were made in agriculture
After the Moderates complained about the policy was adopted in 1934, so that peasants were allowed to own small pieces of landto farm privatly
This helped Russia during the famine in the following years as they could recove quicker
On the Fence
In responce to the fear of imminet war with Germany defence spending rose by 4% in 1933 to 17% in 1937 of all government spending yet it was all at the expence of living standards and consumer goods
Problems with the Second Five Year Plan
The economy was supposed to be planned yet there was little co-ordination between branches of industry, in order to meet targets, factory managers would hoard items that were in short supply to make them scares
Lack of spare parts was experienced in many industires with many machines left idle and unproductive
Fear of exile or execution meant people didn't want criticise the second plan, report errors or suggest that targets were unreasonable
The practice of lying continued from the first plan into the second
Eventhough standard of living increased between 1934-36 there were shortages of essential items with wise housewifes would buy any consumer good they could get their hands on even if they didn't need it, to use or sell at a later stage
The avaliability of shoes became a big issue, 1931 governemnet outlawed private production of shoes due to leather shortages, state provided shoes were such low quality, didn't last, fell apart same day as purchise
Shortages so bad in 1934, 6,000 people queued outside one shop, thepolice had to be called when the shop opened to avoid a riot
Problems with the Second Five Year Plan Continued
Housing and facitilities were a problem during the first plan, second plan also failed to improve this
Not a single bathroom for 650,000 people in the Liubertsky district of Moscow, new houses were also built wiht no running water and sewarage
By the mid 1930's social inequalities began to occur, Stalin stated at the beginning, socialism doesn't entitle wage equality, every society must provide insentives for hard work
Members of the communist party also recieved privilages, with 55,000 senior communists entitled to better food, clothes and accomodation
Stalin's elite entitled chauffeur driven cars, privte houses, limousines, seats in cinemas and operas. Also had access to 'secret shops' which contained comsumer goods unavaialble to public
However most party members still worse off than average peson in Britain at the time
Related discussions on The Student Room
- year 13 study journal // gyg 2023-24 :) »
- Go ahead in time as far as possible »
- When's your birthday »
- What Should I pick for my Year 13 History Option »
- Messed up in terms of timing + info in A-Level History AQA, how will this affect me? »
- A Level - History coursework - which question is the best//most interesting »
- OCR A Level History Non-British period study: All Exams - 22 Jun 2022 [Exam Chat] »
- Quiz of the Week: The Master Thread! »
- Edexcel A Level History Paper 1 (9HI0 1A-1H) - 24th May 2023 [Exam Chat] »
- Guide: Which Language Should I Study? »
Comments
No comments have yet been made