Sociology - Families and Households

HideShow resource information

Functionalists

  • Family is an essential function for society and its members 
  • Family is universal and plays positive role in society 
  • Nuclear Family = good for industrial society because its small and mobile 

Murdock

  • Study - 250 societies and arugued family is universal 
  • Family performs 4 functions: 
  • Sexual - provides and controls sexual access 
  • Reproductive - provides new members 
  • Economic - provide food, warmth, home etc 
  • Educational - provides socialisation 

Parsons 

  • Family performs 2 basic functions:
  • Primary socialisation of children 
  • Stabilisation of adult personalities 

Men = Instrumental        Women = Expressive

1 of 10

Criticisms of Funtionalists

  • Family is not universal - number of alternatives 
  • Nuclear family is becoming minority in some societies 
  • Nuclear family was common in pre-industrial society 

Marxists Criticisms 

  • Ignores conflict 
  • Very conservative so defends the status quo - doesnt allow change 
  • Family fulfills the needs of the economy, rather than its members 
  • The view that the family is 'normal' is ideological 

Feminists Criticisms

  • Justifies womens oppression 
  • In other societies - men and women take differnt roles (Oakley)
  • Nuclear family produces misery and problems as well as harmony (Radical Psychiatrists)
2 of 10

Marxists

  • Society serves the interests of capitalism 
  • Family provides workers 
  • These workers are socialised by the family to obey and conform
  • The family acts as a safety valve (Zaretsky) 
  • By giving workers responsibility = encourages them to work 
  • Provides consumers to buy goods by economy 
  • The family acts as an 'ideological state apparatus' defending the status quo, patriarchy and role of wife

Engles 

  • Society = rise in private property, men needed property so be passed to their offspring = monogamy arose, women were brought into the home under domination of men
3 of 10

Criticisms of Marxists

  • Too based on modern western society 
  • Seen to be too biased and negative 
  • Presumes universal nuclear family where man works and women stays home 
  • Too deterministic, it assumes the dominance of economy 
  • Does not explain similarities in family structure in different societies 

Feminists Criticisms 

  • Sees the family as serving the interests of men, patriarchy and capitalism 
4 of 10

Feminists

  • See the family as serving interests of partiarchy 
  • Family life is different for women adn is a source of male control over women 
  • Feminists see previous views of the family as 'malestream' (Abbott and Wallace)

Marxist Feminists 

  • Sees women are oppressed by capitalism and patriarchy 
  • Argue that women produce and socialise new workers, producing profit for economy (Benston)
  • Women also provide a 'reserve army' - cheap, temporary workers (Bruegal)

Liberal Feminists 

  • See increasing gender equality through law and changing values 
  • Claim that power relations and division of labour within marriage = more equal,

Radical Feminists

  • Nuclear family = based and supporting male power (Firestone)
  • Socialisation of mother/housewife role is seen as a form of oppression 
5 of 10

Criticisms of Feminists

  • Feminists have over estimated the extent of female inequality 
  • Women have gained more choices and family life is more diverse 
  • Focus on the negative aspects of family life 
  • Assume all families are male headed who dominate the rest

Black Feminists 

  • Other feminists fail to consider the influence of racism as well as patriarchy

New Right 

  • Claim feminists undermine traditional family values 
6 of 10

Postmodernism

  • Stresses the pluralism, diverstity and fragmentation of modern life 
  • There cannot be one dominant, most common or 'correct' type of family 
  • There can be no 'normal' or 'natural' form of family relationships or roles - nuclear family has become fragmented
  • Important aspect of postmodern family is the ability for the individual to make choices are for members to make or construct their families through intereaction 
7 of 10

Criticisms of Postmodernists

  • Avoids generalisations and allows us to see the individual meanings of social life 
  • Postmodernists ideas show the possibility to greater choice rather than oppression
  • Some see postmodernism as a dead-end  

Giddens

Suggests that postmodernist ideas have led to the rise of a more reflexive approach to social life

8 of 10

New Right

  • Conservative policies
  • The building block of society 
  • Seperate roles by men and women = biological 
  • All other arrangements are 'deviant' and therefore a threat to society
  • Main Concern= family is under threat and breaking down. 
  • Welfare dependancy is an issue 
  • Changes in social values is an issue 
9 of 10

Criticisms of New Right

  • Abbott and Wallace see New Right ideas as a form of patriarchy 
  • Labels groups like lone-parents and homosexuals as a threat to society 

Marxist Criticisms

  • Sees New Right as ideology for capitalism 
  • Argue that poverty and inequality is due to the system and way society is structured, not the individual
10 of 10

Comments

No comments have yet been made

Similar Sociology resources:

See all Sociology resources »See all Families and households resources »