+ Much of the research into obedience uses experimental methods such as Milgram and Hofling et al and so there are strong controls over extraneous variables and methodology is replicable.
+ Meeus and Raaijmakers found the same as Milgram; blind obedience occurred in both cases although this was in the Netherlands and twenty years after Milgrams (1963) study which suggests that it is a valid explanation across many cultures and strengthens the research as similar findings are obtained.
- It could be argued that the Netherlands isn’t too different a culture from the USA and so generalising the theory to other cultures which are elementally different might still be difficult.
- Milgram used agency theory to describe obedience whilst Zimbardo suggested situation caused obedience rather than personality. Other theories include that of social power and the numerous theories may affect how the theories are used to contribute to society; there is no one definitive explanation.
Comments
No comments have yet been made