-Strengths: Simplicity- Simplicty of application in Benthem's application, easy to use. Common sense- Moral judgements fit with our commonsense view of morality. Tries to make the world better- Promotes happiness. Flexible- Allows each situation to be judged differently
- Weaknesses: Pleasure is not the highest form people aspire to- Minority people get can be exploited. W.D Ross- Argued that lifes ethical dilemmmas cannot be answered with a simple calculus that balances outcomes, We have duties that take priority over the "greater good". Measuring pleasure- Possible to measure pleasure? Pleasure is a subjective concept
-Strengths: No counterintuitive consequences- Higher & lower pleasures- Mill overcomes this problem. Equality- Mill adds equal rights. Common sense- The moral judgement fits with our commonsense view of morality, Mill's version argues we should generally follow rules
-Weaknesses: Elitislt- Mill says that an intellectual man is capable of making true moral decision making- Implies that only most educated can be the most moral, since they "have experianced the best things in life". Alasidair Macintyre- Mill is an "inconsistent Utilitarinism", we use generations of past experiances to form rules
Comments
No comments have yet been made