Reasons for Gender Differences in Education (Girls' Overachievement)

?
  • Created by: 11JimDan
  • Created on: 23-02-17 12:48

Trends (Gender)

  • 1980s - Females were underacheiving; 1990s - Girls began to outperform males
  • Present - Crisis of male underachievment

                 - Girls do better in SATs, GCSEs (except Science)

                 - Girls do better in English (2/3 achieve A*-C compared to 1/2 boys)

                 - Girls are more likely to get into Sixth Form, achieve their A-Levels and get accepted into University

                 - Girls are more likely to get Distinctions in vocational subjects

1 of 17

Feminist Movement and Women's Rights (External)

  • Feminist movement and Women's Rights - Sex Discrimination Act 1975

                                                                    - Abortion Reform Act 1969

                                                                    - Divorce Reform Act 1970

  • McRobbie - Content analysis - Compared girls magazines in the 1970s and 1990s

                                               - Women now have more positive role models and marriage is less of a priority. 

2 of 17

Evaluation (Feminist Movement and Women's Rights)

  • Women are still expected to do the 'triple shift' (work, housework and emotional work)
  • Women still take more maternity leave - Many feminists still argue that the world is still very patriarchal
3 of 17

Changes in the Family (External)

  • Increased divorce rates
  • Decreased marriage rates
  • Decline in birth rates
  • Increase in single parent families (female-led)
  • Smaller family sizes
  • Increase in co-habitation
4 of 17

Evaluation (Changes in the Family)

  • Women are still expected to do the 'triple shift' (work, housework, emotional work)
  • Women still take more maternity leave - Many feminists argue that the world is still very patriarchal
5 of 17

Employment Opportunities for Women (External)

  • Sex Discrimination Act 1975
  • Equal Pay Act 1970
  • Women in employment increased from 47% in 1959 to 70% in 2007.
  • Earnings gap has fallen from 30% to 17%
  • Francis - Interviewed girls in 2001 - Said the had high aspirations
6 of 17

Evaluation (Employment Opportunities for Women)

  • Women are still expected to do the 'triple shift' (work, housework, emotional work)
  • There's still an earnings gap
  • Women still take more maternity leave - Many feminists still argue that the world is still very patriarchal
7 of 17

Changing Social Attitudes & Perceptions (External)

  • Combination of the previous arguments changed society's views of women's capabilities
8 of 17

Evaluation (Changing Social Attitudes & Perception

  • Women are still expected to do the 'triple shift' (work, housework and emotional work)
  • There is an earnings gap
  • Many feminists argue that the world is still very patriarchal
9 of 17

Positive Role Models (Internal)

  • 'Feminisation of Education' - Study in 2007 found thyat 84% of primary school teachers are women; 61% of 8-11 year olds have had no male teachers
10 of 17

Evaluation (Positive Role Models)

  • Radical feminists would say school is still very patriarchal
  • Male teachers are more likely to become headteachers
  • History is still mainly taught by men
11 of 17

Equal Opportunity Policies (Internal)

  • Since the feminist movement, there has been a drive in schools to boost girls' grades
  • Education Reform Act 1988 - Introduced National Curriculum which puts both genders into the same courses
  • WISE (Women Into Science & Engineering)/GIST (Girls Into Science & Technology)
  • Weiner - Teachers are challenging gender sterotypes more
12 of 17

Evaluation (Equal Opportunity Policies)

  • Radical feminists would say that school is still very patriarchal
  • Radical feminists would say that there is not a lot of choice
  • Liberal feminists would say that this is progress for gender equality
  • History is still mainly taught by men
13 of 17

GCSEs and Coursework (Internal)

  • Gorard - Gender gap increased with GCSEs that had a lot of coursework (Girls did better)
  • Mitsos and Browne - Girls are more organised, spend more time on work and care more about presentationn (Socialisation)
14 of 17

Evaluation (GCSEs and Coursework)

  • Radical feminists would say that there is not a lot of choice
  • Liberal feminists would say that this is good progress for gender equality
  • Courseowork argument is flawed - Exams are worth more than coursework
15 of 17

Labelling (Internal)

  • Becker - Halo effect
  • Rosenthal and Jacobson - Self-Fulfilling Prophecy
  • Keddie - Unequal access to classroom knowledge
  • Swann - Boys dominate discussions in class
  • Francis - Boys are more likely to be disciplined as girls are left to work quietly (Becker - Labelling)
  • Cream skimming and silt shifting
16 of 17

Evaluation (Labelling)

  • Deterministic
  • Labels do not always stick
  • Liberal feminists would say that this is good progress for gender equality
17 of 17

Comments

No comments have yet been made

Similar Sociology resources:

See all Sociology resources »See all Education resources »