qwergh
- Created by: jatyization
- Created on: 22-01-15 00:06
Turning to Crime
Upbringing
- Farrington
- Sutherland
- Wikstrom and Tafel
Farrington
Aim: Document start, duration and end of offending behaviour and it invesitgate the ffect of life efents; risk and protective factors predicting offending behaviour
Procedure: Lonlitudinal study of 411 boys aged 8-9. Boys were taken from registers of state schools in east london and were predominantly white middle class. 93% interviewed
Results:
- 161 criminal convictions
- Offences peaked at 17
- 93% commited one offence according ot self report
- 7% chronic offenders
Conclusion
- Offenders are deviant in many areas of their lives
- Important risk factors for ciminality: Impulsiveness, poor child rearinfg and poor school preformance
- Early intervention programmes = singificant impact
Sutherland- Differential Association Hypothesis
1) Criminal Behaviour is learned
2) Criminal behaviour is learned in interaction with other persons in a process of communication
3) Principle part of learning of criminal behaviour occurs within intimate personal groups
4) When criminal behaviour is learned, the learning includes the techniques of commiting the crime, which are soemtimes very complicated, soemtimes very simple and the specific direction of motives, desires and rationalisations and attitudes
5) Specific direction of motives and drives is learned from definitions of the legal codes as favourable or unfavourable
6) Person becomes delinquent becaus eof an excess of definitions favourable to violation of law over definitions unfavourable to violation of law
7) Differential associations my vary in frequency, duration, priority and intensity
8) Process of learning cirminal behaviour by association with criminal and anti criminal patterns involves all of the mechanisms that are involved in any other learning
9) While cirminal behaviour is an expression of general needs and values, it is not explained by those general needs and values since non criminal behaviour is an expression of the same needs and values
Summary: 1) Deviance occurs when a certain human situation is defined as an appropariate occasion for violating social normals or criminal laws 2) Definitions of the situations are aquired through an individuals history os past experiences
Wikstrom & Tafel- The Peterborough Youth Study
Aim: To investigate why young people offend
Procedure: Cross sectional study carried out on 2000 year 10 students. Data acollected from interviews and official reports
Results:
- 44.8% of males and 30.6% females had offended
- High frequency offenders commit a wide range of crimes
- One in eight reported to be cuaght by the police in last offense
- More likely to be victims of violence and substance abuse
Explanatory factors: Family social position; Indivdual characteristics; Social situation; Lifetsyle; Community context
Conclusion:
- Propensity induced: Many risk factors and have enduring propensity to offend
- Lifetstyle Dependent: Average social adjustment but offend due to high risk lifestyle
- Situationally limited: Youth occasionally offend due to situation they are in (fight)
Cognition
Cognition
- Yochelson & Samenow- Criminal thinking patterns
- Kohlberg- Moral Development
- Gudjohnsson- Attribution
Yochelson & Samenow
Aim: Understand make up of criminal personality and to establish techniques to alter cime producing personality. Also to encourage legal responsibility and techniques to prevent cirminal behabviour
Procedure: Longlitudinal sudy; 255 male participants from various backgrounds; Population mainly confined to mental hospital; 30 completed interviews
Findings: Criminals are:
- Restless, dissatisfied and irritable
- Considered requests from teachers as impositions while at school
- Ostracised themselves
- lack empathy
- habitually angry
Conclusions:
- 52 thinking patterns were distinguished in criminal personality
- Errors in thinking
- No control group
Kohlberg
Aim: Find evidence in support of a progression through stages of moral development
Procedure: 58 working and middle class boys from chicago; Aged 7, 10 13 and 16; Given interviews with 10 ethical dillemas; Repeated in UK, Mexico and Taiwan
Findings:
- Younger boys at pre-mortality and conventional morality stage
- Older boys at post conventional morality
Conclusion: Evidence does support the idea of a stage theory. Recent studies show that criminals offending for finnacial gain are morally immature than those for violent crimes
Gudjohnsson & Bownes
Aim: To examine relationship between the type of offense and attributions offenders make about their criminal acts
Procedure: 80 criminals; Northern ireland; 20 violent crimes; 40 sex offenders; 20 crimes against property; Answered GBAI
Findings:
- Violent offence had mild guilt; mild mental element; highest external attribution
- Sexual offences had highest guilt; highest mental element; lowest external attribution
- Property offences had least guilt; lowest mental element; Mild external element
Conclusion: Comparison between these and english findings from earlier study show similarities in results but a higher level of external attribution in northern ireland was found because of 'troubles' in northern ireland in 1980's and 1990's
Biology
Biology
- Raine- Brain dysfunction
- Brunner- Genes
- Gender- Daly & Wilson
Raine
Aim: Make a multi-factor approach to understanding antiscoial and agressive behaviour in children
Procedure: Meta analysis of a selection of articles covering neuropsychological, neurological and brain-immaging studies as they relate to anti-scoial behaviour in children
Findings:
- Low resting heart rate = predictor of someone who seeks excitement to raise arousal level, creating fearless temperament
- Adolescent pre-frontal lobe still forming
- Birth complications, poor parenting, smoking and malnutrition is also a factor. (enviromental cosnsiderations = less reductionist)
Conclusions: Early interventions and prevention may be an effective way of reversing biological deficits that predispose to antisocial and agressive behaviour
Brunner
Aim: Case study on family from netherlands where males were affected by a syndrome of borderline mental retardation and abnormal violent behaviour. These include agression, arson, attempted **** and exhibitionism
Procedure: 5 affected males were studied; Data collected from analysis of urine samples over 24 hours
Findings:
- Tests showed distributed monoamine metabolism with a deficit of MAOA enzyme
- x chromosomal mutation
Conclusions: MOAO is involved in serotonin metabolism, Impaired metabolism of serotonin = linked to mental retardation and aggressive behaviour
Daly & Wilson
Aim: Find out if homocide rates would vary as function of local life expectancy in chicago
Procedure: Correlational study using survery data from police records,s chool records and local demographic records; Average life expectancy from 54.3 compared to homicide
Findings:
- Homicide rate varied from 1.3 to 156 homicides per 100,000 persons per anum
- Correlation between life expectancy and homicide rate was strong
- Lower life expectancy = higher homicide rate
- School absenteeism = negative correlation with life expectancy
Conclusion: Young men from disadvantaged neighbourhoods expected to live shorter lives and were more likely to engage in risky behaviour; Finds explained better by social factors rather than life expectancy
Related discussions on The Student Room
- Ethological explanations aggression »
- Psychology research »
- Should I complain to manager? »
- Marking AQA a-level Psychology Essay: Evaluate and outline the social learning theory »
- Can I get all 10 evaluation marks on a Psych 16 marker without using other studies? »
- poor lecturers / course change »
- Is rough masturbation bad? »
- AQA A level psychology »
- Paper-3 16 marker essays - AQA A-Level Psychology »
- Paper 3 psychology »
Comments
No comments have yet been made