Evidence suggests there is more than one type of short term memory - Shallice and Warrington (1970) studied KF. KF's short term memory digits were poor when they read them out to him but his recall was better when he read the digits himself. The model suggets there is only one short term memory; KF study suggests there is more than one - one to process visual information and one to process audiory information.
Only one kind of rehearsal is explained - Craik and Watkins (1973) suggested there are two types of rehearsal - maintenance and elaborative. Maintenence is explained in the multi-store model of memory; elaborative rehearsal is needed for long term storage. This occurs when people link information to existing knowledge or process it - Lacks reliability
Supporting studies use artificial materials - Researchers often asked participants to recall digits, letters or words. In everyday life people form memories related to all sorts of useful thingssuch as peoples faces and names. This means that the studies cannot be generalised to real life situations - Lacks external validity
Comments
No comments have yet been made