Marxist Theories of Religion

?

Religion as ideology

  • Religion operates ideologically to legitimate the suffering of the poor as something inevitable and god-given.
  • Misleading the poor into believing that their suffering is virtuous and will be rewarded in heaven, (easier for camel to enter eye of a needle). Creating false class conscienceness because it prevents the poor from acting to change their situation. 
  • Lenin - Religion is 'spiritual gas' that intoxicates and confuses the poor to keep them in their place, the ruling class manipulate the masses & stop any revolutions by creating a 'mystical fog' that obscures reality. 
  • Christian Fundamentalist groups in the U.S have a history of opposition to communism/socialism, they also believe and prosperity is a sign of God's favour; whilst poverty, or homosexuality are indicators of sin. 
  • Religion legitimates the power & privilege of the dominant class by making their power appear to be divinely ordained, e.g, Divine Right of Kings - the king is God's representative on Earth and if you disobey it's illegal and a sinful challenge to Gods's authority. 
  • Also the Hindu Caste system which is a social stratification based on ascribed class status, you're born into the same caste as your parents and can't marry between castes. Lowest  are the untouchables who don't have a caste. 
1 of 3

Alienation

  • Marx - Alienation is becoming seperated or feeling out of control from something that one has produced or created. 
  • Under capitalism workers do not own what they produce and have no control over the production process, they can't express their true nature as creative beings.
  • The peak of alienation in capitalism is in the factory where the worker repeats the same meaningless, skilless task in dehuminising conditions.
  • Religion acts as an opiate for the masses, dulling the pain of exploitation but it is only a mask that doesn't tackle the cause of the pain.
  • Religion becomes a distorted view of the world that offers no solution to earthly misery. Illusory happiness distracts the attention away from capitalism - the true source of suffering.
2 of 3

Criticisms

  • Functionalism - Ignores positive functions of religion, such as psychological adjustment to misfortune.
  • Neo-Marxists - Certain forms of religion can develop class-conscienceness. 
  • Althusser - Rejects alienation as unscientific and based on a romantic idea that humans have a 'true self', making it an inadequate basis for a theory of religion. 
  • Religion doesn't always function effectively as ideology to control the population, in a pre-capitalist society Christianity was a major element of ruling-class ideaology but it only had limited impact on the peasantry. 
3 of 3

Comments

No comments have yet been made

Similar Sociology resources:

See all Sociology resources »See all Religion and beliefs resources »