Liberalism
- Created by: KDallers-
- Created on: 11-05-19 07:30
Introduction to Liberalism
Liberalism is a MAINSTREAM THEORY that accepts the status quo and attempts to change the world within the existing framework
HERITAGE: emerges in 17th century with Locke's response to Hobbes, decrying the 'state of nature'; later developed with Adam Smith, Jeremy Bentham, Immanuel Kant and J.S Mill
Has a few basic premises: - a positive view of human nature (belief that man is inherently good and can act accordingly), - positive-sum with absolute gains to be made, - anarchy can be overcome through cooperation (belief that humans can cooperate)
Summarised by Kegley's 6 principles:
- Human nature = good, - progress stems from a desire to improve, - structural influences are important, - anarchy does NOT render war inevitable, - cooperation can stop war, - international society needs to be reordered
Utopian (First Generation) Liberalism
Following the 17th century/Enlightement, liberalism was particularly prevalent post-WWI with the ideas of WOODROW WILSON; believed in war being stopped through cooperation and the role of 'international organisations' - like the League of Nations - institutionalism
- Attempting to "make the world safe for democracy"; believed that LIBERAL DEMOCRATISATION would stop authoritarianism, which would stop war; also favoured SELF-DETERMINATION - overall, Wilson wanted COOPERATION through RATIONAL ORGANISATION
- Norman Angell - interdependence and globalisation made cooperation a necessity - called for greater diplomacy and cooperation due to this; no place for militarism; focussing on GOOD OF INDIVIDUALS rather than SOVEREIGN STATES
- Jeremy Bentham - the principle of the 'greatest good for the greatest number' applies to cooperation; believed we should guarantee this through 'international law'
- DEMOCRATISATION - stems from Kant 'Perpetual Peace' and Doyle's Democratic Peace Theory; democracies do not fight democracies, so DEMOCRATISATION is an objective; if DEMOCRACY could be transferred to the international system (domesticating it), ideal. - Undermined by the rise of 1930s authoritarianism and militarism, and the failure of the League, as well as the Great Depression
Neo (Second Generation) Liberalism
Emerged towards the end of the Cold War; COOPERATION through various institutions showed that war was not inevitable; now new 'regimes', more globalisation and democratisation
- KEGLEY - predicated on the idea that "there is an international sosciety"; believed in the possibility of cooperation and a challenge to anarchy, without forming a hierarchy; relates to Kegley's 6 principles - WAR DOES NOT HAVE TO HAPPEN
- Led to regional integration (due to neofunctional beliefs - HAAS), the demise of protectionism and 'borders', and increased cooperation
- Saw DEMOCRACY as the ULTIMATE FORM OF GOVERNANCE; if domestically 'people' were in charge of government, the same can be done with states and the international system = cooperation and peace
- Based around REASON OVER FEAR and the "possibility of cumulative progress" (Keohane); a belief in a certain set of liberal institutions like THE MARKET, WELFARE STATES, THE RULE OF LAW and INTERCONNECTION/GLOBALISATION
Forms of Neoliberalism (Jackson + Sorenson)
- SOCIOLOGICAL - belief in transnational ties over state borders developing peace; individuals in the world work to provide a SENSE OF GLOBAL COMMUNITY - operational on the STATE not being the only actor; supported by Karl Deutsch, and Rosenau, who said there was a "multi-centric world of diverse "sovereignty-free collectivities" - cooperation between individuals
- INTERDEPENDENCE - due to globalisation, nations now affect other nations more than ever; movement of labour and financial capital (both desirable) - trade is more important than militarism - more integration guarantees peace ("shifting loyalties to a new centre" - Haas); promotion of 'low' over 'high' politics (Keohane and Nye Jr.); overall GROWTH OF TRANSNATIONALISM over militarism
- INSTITUTIONAL - institutions are beneficial, and can be used to promote cooperation - can be organisations, or 'regimes'; Keohane's measure of STRENGTH an institution: - commonality of behaviour, - specificity and - autonomy; institutions help cooperation through integration (Haas)
- REPUBLICAN - based around Doyle and Kant; democracies don't go to war and are inherently peaceful, so we should spread liberal democratisation; a normative theory based around shared political culture, common morality and interdependency
- Overall; all share beliefs which suggest there is no alternative to liberalism - Fukuyama
Criticisms of Liberalism
1) TOO OPTIMISTIC? Waltz 1959 "you have misestimated human nature"; there is less possibility of cooperation for progress, less chance of democratisation working and less chance of capitalist ideals succeeding
2) INSTITUTIONALISM - institutions fail to affect conflicts (Iraq), and undermine the idea that great powers and weak states exist; multipolarity is destined to fail (Mearsheimer)
3) DEMOCRACY ISN'T PERMANENT - some states are destined to revert back to authoritarianism due to their political cultures - for example, Germany post-WWI (Weimar Republic failed), also various Middle Eastern nations
4) WESTERN-CENTRISM - liberal democracy may not be an aim for ALL states; Western governance is not best for all and some may feel alienated from the "international society"
5) LIBERAL COLONIALISM - many liberals believe in the subversion of other nations in the name of 'democracy' or 'cooperation'; organisations facilitate this, and represents neoimperalism through 'Western liberal values' - CORE nations challenging the PERIPHERY (Wallerstein)
*DIFFERENCES BETWEEN CRITICAL AND CONVENTIONAL THE
Cox: "Theory is always there for someone and for some purpose"
PROBLEM-SOLVING (MAINSTREAM)
- POSTIVIST - using existing structures to deal with things; accept limitations and deal with these within the framework; examples of realism and 'anarchy' and liberalism and peace
- POWER-RELATED - concerned with 'high politics' of power and security dilemmas resulting from power relations; all about the balance and accumulation of power - Mearsheimer and liberal view on BoP
CRITICAL THEORY
- POST-POSITIVIST - challenging existing structures and changing the framework; an 'appraisal of the framework' (Cox); seeks historical change of the framework - poststructuralists and language, postcolonialists and imperialism/race
- NOT ABOUT POWER - challenging power relations and focussing on the marginalised; argue people need emancipating from power relations (Ken Booth and 'emancipatory theory')
Key Liberal Thinkers
Historically - Locke, Smith, Kant, Bentham
Utopian - Wilson, Angell
Neo - Kegley, Keohane, Nye Jr., Haas (neofunctionalist)
Sociological - Deutsch, Rosenau
Critics: Waltz (REALIST), Said, Fanon (POSTCOLONIAL), Wallterstein (world-systems), Foucault, Derrida (POSTSTRUCTURAL)
Related discussions on The Student Room
- Core ideology essay »
- Liberal Arts BA at KCL »
- Liberal Arts »
- liberal arts @ Bristol »
- liberal arts vs combined hons social science »
- Liberal Arts Course »
- A level Edexcel Politics »
- Liberal arts in warwick or finance in Durham (undergrad) »
- Best unis for a Liberal Arts degree? »
- AQA A-Level Politics Paper 3 - 7152/3 16 June 2023 [Exam chat] »
Comments
No comments have yet been made