Language and Gender
- Created by: chloemartin97
- Created on: 18-04-16 10:15
DeClerk
Women swear just as much as men
Coates
Men turn take in same sex convo, women speak simultaneously.
Obar and Atkins
power = dominance (courtroom research).
Byng and Bergwall
diversity model = social background dictates language
Deborah Cameron
diversity model = more differences between the same gender.
Trudgill
Norwich - men use covert prestige, women use overt prestige.
Otto Jesperson (1922)
Deficit model = female language is unfinished/avoid complex syntax
Shirley and Edwin Ardener
Dominance model
Lakoff (1956)
Women's language - deficit model - women regarded as weaker sex
Janet Holmes
referential / affective tag questions - men more referential
Deborah Tannen
Difference model - men and women brought up in different environments
Pamela Fishman
division of labour - women work harder in conversation
Janet Hyde
difference between men and women is close to zero
Zimmerman
men are dominant
Zimmerman and West
men interrupt more
Beattie
interruptions might mean support rather than dominance
Jane Pilkington (1992)
women in same sex talk more collaborative. Women use positive politeness / men less supportive
Koenraad Kuiper (1991)
men's rugby team. insults a sign of solidarity. men don't worry about saving face
Germaine Greer
female comedy comments on blog - common women's themes are bras, period, chocolate and Weightwatchers
Mills (1991)
feminine style of speech used for social control - women carefully monitor behaviour to ensure that it's appropriate
Norman Fairclough
Synthetic personalisation - making it sound like you are speaking to an individual when addressing a mass audience e.g. "see you after the break"
Lecercle
people ask questions to demonstrate power
Eakins and Eakins (1976)
men speak for longer
Edelsky (1981)
men take longer turns / joke more, argue more, direct more
Herbert and Straight (1989)
compliments flow from those of higher rank to those of lower rank
Herring (1992)
email discussion - 5 women, 30 men took part, even though women nearly 50% of members. Men's messages twice as long. women use personal voice, men assertive
Holmes (1998)
women managers more likely to negotiate consensus than males - take more time to make sure everyone is in agreement
Holmes and Marra (2002)
women use just as much humour as men, and for same functions, although they are more likely to encourage supportive and collaborative humour
Hornyak (1994)
shift from work talk to personal talk always initiated by highest ranking person in the room
Tracy and Eisenberg (1990/91)
role playing delivering criticism to co-worker about errors in business letter. men showed more concern for feelings of person they were criticising when in subordinate role, while women showed more concern when in the superior role
Related discussions on The Student Room
- A level English language paper 2 NEA ideas »
- A Level English Language Investigation ideas »
- English Language Investigation Ideas »
- NEA coursework »
- English Lang paper 2 »
- English language paper 2 »
- Please answer this short questionnaire! »
- German Grammar Help »
- A-Level English »
- A Level Edexcel English Language - Language Investigation »
Comments
No comments have yet been made